Anyone Ever Buy and/or Sell on Tradesy?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Did you all get the recent 'closet snapshot' email? I didn't find mine very helpful. What does 'recent closet activity' even mean? The last week? Month? 3 months?
Yes I did. It must have been more than a week ago because I have more items in my closet now. The numbers are dismal, if the time period is more than a week. I have just a little more views than I have items, and since apparently 11 of those views are of my most popular item, that means many items aren't getting seen at all.
 
I listed an item on Tradesy and ebay about a week ago. On ebay it has had 104 views and 7 favorites. Not a single favorite on Tradesy. There is so little activity on Tradesy. I bet they don't show you how many views you've gotten because it is so low.
 
That is so not okay. I'd be livid. I hope everything turns out okay.

All of my returns have been in the same condition up until now. (I've had maybe 5 returned to me in the past 15 months).
This week someone is returning my Chanel with "damaged closure". The button was working fine when I shipped it and I never had a problem. I see by the tracking that she got the bag Friday morning, and filed a return Monday...so lets see what the bag looks like when it gets back to me. Very stressful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: domifreaka
Posh is very busy, but im getting a ton of "how do I know its real" buyers and a ton of people that think they know the brand when they don't. I had a lady who said an LV was fake because it was made in Spain, another one saying all real chanels have authenticity stickers, etc. I guess it's harder when they make it so easy to comment under the listings.
True, posh is busy but people ask ridic Qs and keep bugging you. they demand additional images even though ALL the pictures with details and codes for authentication are already posted. then they never buy or they make you an insulting offer. I stopped posting mod pictures because such requests never come from serious buyers. But small things are moving fast on Posh. Huge traffic.
 
Last edited:
True, posh is busy but people ask ridic Qs and keep bugging you. they demand additional images even though ALL the pictures with details and codes for authentication are already posted. then they never buy or they make you an insulting offer. I stopped posting mod pictures because such requests never come from serious buyers. But small things are moving fast on Posh. Huge traffic.

Exactly. There is a great Posh fb group where I learned a lot though. Share listings every hour, follow 1k people a day, never decline an offer, etc. Basically treat it as a full time job and sales will come haha
I must say though, the "always counteroffer" thing is so true. Sometimes I get crazy low offers, counter and they come back with double of what they initially offered. I guess to feel out the seller. So now even when I have a Chanel listed at $999 and someone offers $200 I counter with $980 :amuse:
 
Exactly. There is a great Posh fb group where I learned a lot though. Share listings every hour, follow 1k people a day, never decline an offer, etc. Basically treat it as a full time job and sales will come haha
I must say though, the "always counteroffer" thing is so true. Sometimes I get crazy low offers, counter and they come back with double of what they initially offered. I guess to feel out the seller. So now even when I have a Chanel listed at $999 and someone offers $200 I counter with $980 :amuse:
I don't do Facebook or social media. It makes it harder to sell my items when this is what you need to do to make sales. I think this is why my sales on etsy dried up.
 
Posh is very busy, but im getting a ton of "how do I know its real" buyers and a ton of people that think they know the brand when they don't. I had a lady who said an LV was fake because it was made in Spain, another one saying all real chanels have authenticity stickers, etc. I guess it's harder when they make it so easy to comment under the listings.

yes, it's really annoying, and these comments are not removable, but there are still a lot of good buyers who know what they buy and know the brand.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GemsBerry
I relisted my ten shirts with a new picture of them piled up together rather than the collage, and it hasn't been removed. They cleaned the picture. So the collage must have been the reason it was removed.
When they removed your listing, did they send you a message to let you know (as eBay does)? Or do you have to figure it out yourself? And if they send a message, does it tell you why, i.e., counterfeit or another violation?
 
When they removed your listing, did they send you a message to let you know (as eBay does)? Or do you have to figure it out yourself? And if they send a message, does it tell you why, i.e., counterfeit or another violation?
They didn't send anything. I had no idea why it was removed. It just went poof. I guessed what it was, and I must be right since the new listing with the new photo is still up.
 
I listed an item on Tradesy and ebay about a week ago. On ebay it has had 104 views and 7 favorites. Not a single favorite on Tradesy. There is so little activity on Tradesy. I bet they don't show you how many views you've gotten because it is so low.
I asked about the time frame and did get a response...the time frame for their stats is a 90 day period. Now THAT info is helpful for me. Pretty dismal compared to eBay for me.
 
They didn't send anything. I had no idea why it was removed. It just went poof. I guessed what it was, and I must be right since the new listing with the new photo is still up.
That's weird, IMO. If you have just a few listings and they remove one of them, it's pretty easy to narrow down what was removed. But if you have dozens of listings, it could be days, weeks or even never that you realize that a listing is gone.

I wonder why there's no notice of a takedown.
 
I asked about the time frame and did get a response...the time frame for their stats is a 90 day period. Now THAT info is helpful for me. Pretty dismal compared to eBay for me.
That is extremely dismal!! Much worse than I thought. It would have been dismal for the period of a week. I got just a few more views than I have items. On ebay, I get that much in a hour.
That's weird, IMO. If you have just a few listings and they remove one of them, it's pretty easy to narrow down what was removed. But if you have dozens of listings, it could be days, weeks or even never that you realize that a listing is gone.

I wonder why there's no notice of a takedown.
There is no notice because Tradesy is poorly run! I always know exactly how many listings I have since I check several times a day to see if the number has changed. Sometimes you can make a sale and you won't be notified about it for hours or even a day, but the item will move from your active listings to sold, so that is what I'm looking for. It was easy to find which one was missing in this case because I had just added it and it was the only item in its category.
 
I had a rare case of return because Tiffany bracelet didn't fit (how it's even possible, it's standard size). anyway, Tradesy is holding my funds for over a week since they received return from the customer. I emailed them twice, they are still "reviewing" it. there's nothing to review, auth with original packaging in like new condition. Why do they need to "review" such a small item that is easy to process. unless they are wearing it that is...
 
  • Like
Reactions: whateve
Top