I really think there is no doubt the influence of Karl Lagerfeld is greater than that of Slimane! He is arguably one of the most influential fashion figures alive, and he has defined the standard for creative director, I.e., a designer of another brand name. I would also argue that Philo’s influence is more enduring, but that is just me and maybe wistful thinking.
What is interesting about this collection is that it questions the whole KL model of brand building. Basically Slimane is saying, I do Slimane using well established ateliers of I don’t care which brand. Why doesn’t he design under his own name? Boundaries are blurring.
It is true that Celine’s brand identity is weaker than that of other houses. However it did have an underlying essence which had to do with the bien penssante petite burgeoisie, very French, very proper. Both Kors and Philo played with this identity. Yes, the Philo woman went less for lunch and more to galleries, but neither were the disco party girl. They had left that behind and were unapologetically living a serious mature life. This collection of Slimane caters exclusively for the young girl on a party night. it is a complete reversal of identity. LVMH know that with this collection they are alinieting every single client who bought Celine clothes in the last decades: they are all gone from one day to the next. And they don’t care. Basically, what they are saying is that they are not interested in that client. Food for thought.
There is a lot to think about on the state of fashion after this show. But what I found most upsetting is how very lazy it was. I liked him at Dior Homme, But this really looked like a student project “in the manner of Slimane”. There was not even the pretence that either fashion and design (let alone art) or couture and craftsmanship had any play in it. It was unabashedly a set up to sell, with nothing behind, just the pure raw business and marketing tools exposed in all their glory. I am glad that a couple of fashion critics are being brave and speaking up that the skinny Emperor has no new clothes on.