Thank you for clarifying. I see your point. As a follower of his, I believe that he restrained himself for this collection to build a basic foundation of classic suits, trenches, jackets, etc., and that he may branch out into less expected directions in the future. I don’t know that he will veer into classic Celine sportswear categories, but I believe he will experiment more.
As for the casting, he has been very skinny since he was young, and that’s a big part of his identity. He talked about it in the interview he gave to Yahoo in 2015. It’s defiant and self-affirming for him to emphasize that silhouette rather than to cover it up with baggy clothes to appear more masculine. It’s about being true to himself and not conforming to what society says is the “right” way for him to look. The skinny silhouette is what speaks to him the most, and that’s reflected in the casting.
I don’t know to what extent young girls and boys are looking at this collection and comparing themselves but I agree that it’s irresponsible. Clearly he is not thinking about issues of diversity in terms of weight or race, which I agree is unfortunate. I think he is very concerned about not compromising his vision and so he doesn’t listen to critics. He is doing whatever he wants and this probably isn’t even on his radar.
Do you like...work for him or something. You're always defending. It's general critiques and it's nothing to even defend him over. Literally everyone was disappointed in this just as they were disappointed in him even getting the job. It's basically his same old collection from YSL with 'C' everywhere. We're grown, adult women, and he refuses to design clothes for anyone not chasing after 80's rocker girl dreams. He's basically a one trick pony which is fine if you have your own design house or basically 'are' the design house like Karl with Chanel but he isn't. He basically ctrl c ctrl v'd the whole thing from YSL, we've seen literally all of this before.
In terms of models, he doesn't change either. We all know that young teens are impressionable and when they see underweight models walking the runway, the first thing they pick at is their own weight. They can't control how tall they are or the color of their skin, but they can control their weight.
I'm overall just unimpressed with him and always have been and will likely continue to be.