Not sure why there is a constant comparison with Joel and Alex, and now suddenly Chris Hemsworth is added to the mix? It's almost like an obsession. You can be a fan of both you know? It's not Battle to the Death of the Famous Swedes. Personally, I think Joel is a good actor but I don't follow him much. I don't know how other posters feel about JK but not many from this thread post in his thread on tPF
I feel like your comments are generalising the entire thread when really you're only talking about one poster whose views you obviously don't like (and it's blatantly obvious who that is).
And I mean, I was one of those speculating that
Straw Dogs would be an indie hit, and it failed in spectacular fashion.

The truth is Alex's reviews have been hit and miss, because the bigger films Alex has chosen have been hit and miss as well. IMHO it's a shame that he's done his best work in smaller films like
WMK,
Disconnect,
DoATG and probably
WoE - because these are the films that are niche, indie, critically well-received and just won't get the audience they deserve. His bigger films by comparison, have been blustery missteps ie
Battleship, and he was lucky in that, because he didn't have a big part and he wasn't carrying it.
There's a lot of reviews on
Legend of Tarzan because Warner have made sure this film gets seen by putting Alex & co on the PR pavement plus doing a tonne of screenings. It's showy and they are selling it to the max. You can't blame posters for negative reviews when at the moment it's coming in around 70% not great reviews to around 30% positive.
Owning up to the fact reviews for
LoT are sort of bad, doesn't mean people aren't pulling for Alex to do well.
@BuckeyeChicago - thanks for posting that. It's nice to see someone recognising his other work.