@prepster, nothing is too obvious: I have been waiting for the right red scarf but hadn't considered a solid jacquard red. Bold and understated at the same time--that's a pretty good analog to a power tie. The Zeta is a great thought: I actually tried a different cw in the boutique, but the angularity didn't suit me: bendy lines flatter me more, which is another reason I might be having a hard time. Angularity seems to convey more power than swirls, but maybe I need to get over that? I do love the combination of burgundy, black, and gray: maybe I should be looking for a burgundy and gray bold abstract scarf with bendy lines. Not that I'm particular or anything. ; )
.
PS: What in the world is wrong with me? I reread my wish list here and realized that I have a lovely burgundy BdG dip dye sitting right in my closet that fits all those criteria: the minimal color scheme with burgundy; a classic, not too fussy pattern made more abstract by the dip dye; flatteringly bendy. Exactly what I was looking for, and it turns out I already own it! I am going to give it a test drive with a black outfit today.
Talking about the topic helped me realize that I had unconsciously decided that dip dyes were somehow less formal, which is ridiculous. I wonder what other assumptions I have made that I'm not aware of.
I am laughing so hard at myself right now. This is exactly the kind of help I thought this thread could provide. (I still want that Suite et Poursuite and red Sellier jacquard and Zebra Pegasus maxi twilly, though. Might have to break down and get at least one.)