I have had my large Joy for over a year and it's been great. The leather on mine is beautiful and malleable but the detachable pockets on each side give the tote structure so it doesn't lose its shape when put down. I also like that the strap drop isn't too long like lots of totes these days. I don't like when a tote hangs down so far on me, especially since I'm petite. I love totes and I'm always on the lookout for a good one so this has been a great buy so far!