I've lived in the NYC area for a long time and have been going to Woodbury for years. It definitely used to be better, even great, back when all outlets used to be "real" outlets. Now when I go up, I like to take Shortline, and skip the coupon book for sure-- personally I do not like the hassle of NJ transit to save a few bucks, nor do I like to drive. If I am trying to find something specific, forget it.
These days I think of it as a nice day trip out of the city-- sometimes I even take a day off work alone just to relax and spend a weekday up there. I love the outdoor setting and fresh mountain air around you (it's in a pretty area), and yes, shopping is actually relaxing for me. The stores are definitely better than lots of outlets elsewhere, but not so great that it's a "must do". I sometimes come back empty handed, sometimes laden down with packages.
These days I think of it as a nice day trip out of the city-- sometimes I even take a day off work alone just to relax and spend a weekday up there. I love the outdoor setting and fresh mountain air around you (it's in a pretty area), and yes, shopping is actually relaxing for me. The stores are definitely better than lots of outlets elsewhere, but not so great that it's a "must do". I sometimes come back empty handed, sometimes laden down with packages.