By white shoulder bag do you mean the legacy white shoulder zip?
If so then I would deff get the white shoulder zip. I have it in khaki/ebony and love it.
I do love the Ali too though!!!
I think she means the Legacy white Shoulder Bag.
I went to the store today to order the Ali and I saw the slim tote and fell in love with it so I bought the Slim leather tote in white. I had to order it, they were out of them.Im really glad you posted this thread! Im am stuck between the exact same 2 and trying to decide myself lol!!
Let us know which you choose.