I like the camel ones better (I have a pair of Nine West booties in that color that I've had for years and I wear them every winter!!) BUT, considering your wardrobe colors for fall I think you're best bet would be the blue. I think the camel would look better with denim (all shades) and browns, and the blue deffinitely goes better with what you'll be wearing, not to mention with the gray/black tights.