What’s your unpopular Hermes opinion?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I feel like it used to be "cooler" to mix and match and be casual with your luxury pieces. Now a days there seems to be a lot of elitism/snobbery in some fashion community spaces. It is interesting that head-to-toe designer and "quiet luxury" is "in" during a cost of living crisis. There seemed to be more fashion lovers with high-low creative style in years past imho. Now everyone is wearing chanel on chanel or hermes on hermes to prove they hit every check mark. yes, they can look impeccable, but it's not everyone's style or comfort level (and definitely no where near everyone's budget). also there's unkind ongoing commentary on social media like, "if you wear this but wear that then I think your stuff is fake" or "I think that expensive item actually looks cheap, like you couldnt get the most expensive item in the collection" said by really miserable trolls, I realize. but maybe it's why people stick with a uniform... it feels "safe" from criticism, call it what you want but it's not "cheap" and there's amazing history behind the top luxury brands whether it's your taste or not. it seems more than ever people want to "look a part" that is quite segregated from the rest of society. I realize it has always made it easier to move through society when you look nice, especially as a woman, so I don't blame anyone for wanting to fit in with the uppercrust. but I remember a time where even celebs wore affordable clothing items and handbags, "the cheapest LV bags in the store" and they still looked chic. maybe I am missing something about how fashion tastes must inflate along with COL.
It’s a social media rat race to remain relevant. Unfortunately certain brands appear to facilitate much higher engagement rates than others. Same reason people all play the same songs or do the same silly dance on social media; it’s because the algorithm appears to push what’s trending.
 
An unpopular opinion that I wish I could cross-post into the Paris shopping thread:

PSA: Coming into a boutique (or anywhere!) wearing head-to-toe logo'd Hermès, from bouncing sneakers to a full outfit of RTW and an armful and earful of jewelry plus a scarf and let's throw an H bucket hat on top of that...

makes you look like a cult member, not like an irresistible Birkin magnet. 🦆 🦆 🦆
 
I personally find it fun to be able to mix & match "quiet" and not so "quiet" luxury with medium-priced / mass-market items. The beauty of Hermes accessories to me is that you can make your baseline outfit chic, unique and stylish.

My UO is that dressing head to toe in Hermes does not actually look stylish, it’s just too much, too heavy. Screaming.
 
Last edited:
I personally find it fun to be able to mix & match "quiet" and not so "quiet" luxury with medium-priced / mass-market items. The beauty of Hermes accessories to me that you can make your baseline outfit chic, unique and stylish.

My UO is that dressing head to toe in Hermes does not actually look stylish, it’s just too much, too heavy. Screaming.
I was about to say exactly this...Unless the Hermes RTW is under the radar (Like the pieces @880 wears which dont scream Hermes in the way some of the rtw does).
Also another UO...
I think diamond 'fine jewellery' necklaces depicting Hermes bags are just childish and ugly..
Likewise diamond studded hardware on a Birkin or kelly just looks tacky to me....a statement of wealth not taste.
At least not my definition of taste.
 
An unpopular opinion that I wish I could cross-post into the Paris shopping thread:

PSA: Coming into a boutique (or anywhere!) wearing head-to-toe logo'd Hermès, from bouncing sneakers to a full outfit of RTW and an armful and earful of jewelry plus a scarf and let's throw an H bucket hat on top of that...

makes you look like a cult member, not like an irresistible Birkin magnet. 🦆 🦆 🦆
Or a billboard, in which case I need to be paid. To be fair, I've never been drawn to visible logos which is one of the things that appealed to me about Hermes in the first place. But Social Media has transformed the 'H' and the turnlock into signifiers, and in some ways, the company has leaned into that a bit too hard for my taste design-wise.
 
An unpopular opinion that I wish I could cross-post into the Paris shopping thread:

PSA: Coming into a boutique (or anywhere!) wearing head-to-toe logo'd Hermès, from bouncing sneakers to a full outfit of RTW and an armful and earful of jewelry plus a scarf and let's throw an H bucket hat on top of that...

makes you look like a cult member, not like an irresistible Birkin magnet. 🦆 🦆 🦆

Why stop at RTW? Bring your own H mugs and pull it out when they offer you a drink :D That sure would prove that you’re a serious client :D
 
Why stop at RTW? Bring your own H mugs and pull it out when they offer you a drink :biggrin: That sure would prove that you’re a serious client :biggrin:
An unpopular opinion that I wish I could cross-post into the Paris shopping thread:

PSA: Coming into a boutique (or anywhere!) wearing head-to-toe logo'd Hermès, from bouncing sneakers to a full outfit of RTW and an armful and earful of jewelry plus a scarf and let's throw an H bucket hat on top of that...

makes you look like a cult member, not like an irresistible Birkin magnet. 🦆 🦆 🦆
Heck with the blanket-coat trend going on, you might as well top it off by wrapping an Avalon throw around you and call it day. Like an overstuffed Hermes human burrito.
(And I work at a university, so it's a very real thing :doh:)
 
Last edited:
Thank you @maxroxxherhandbags for your kind compliment.

I got a mini K which I love and use often bc I don’t carry much. But, here is my unpopular opinion. Sometimes a larger bag, in this case a 42 JPG fringe Kelly (one of my favorites, though definitely outdated for many years) or a 32K sellier, prunier box leather, (worn crossbody, with an old fashioned, short shoulder carry strap) is more chic and proportionate to a modern, looser clothing silhouette
IMG_7653.pngIMG_7654.jpeg

ETA: another unpopular opinion is that such a large bag is actually quite impractical and still heavy even if basically carried almost empty.

@benjinito , I’ve often wondered, with the scarcity and long wait times of Hermes China patterns, whether some clients might be tempted to ask to purchase the cups and saucers in use at the store lol. Maybe that’s why the boutique doesn’t serve its complimentary coffee in mosaic au 24 ;)

Another unpopular opinion: though limited edition bags are coveted (and I’m grateful for some of these offers), a simpler bag is definitely more user friendly and versatile. I also never thought I would be a fan of epsom, but it’s really pretty sturdy lol
 
Last edited:
Thank you @maxroxxherhandbags for your kind compliment.

I got a mini K which I love and use often bc I don’t carry much. But, here is my unpopular opinion. Sometimes a larger bag, in this case a 42 JPG fringe Kelly (one of my favorites, though definitely outdated for many years) or a 32K sellier, prunier box leather, (worn crossbody, with an old fashioned, short shoulder carry strap) is more chic and proportionate to a modern, looser clothing silhouette
View attachment 6019687View attachment 6019688

ETA: another unpopular opinion is that such a large bag is actually quite impractical and still heavy even if basically carried almost empty.

@benjinito , I’ve often wondered, with the scarcity and long wait times of Hermes China patterns, whether some clients might be tempted to ask to purchase the cups and saucers in use at the store lol. Maybe that’s why the boutique doesn’t serve its complimentary coffee in mosaic au 24 ;)

Another unpopular opinion: though limited edition bags are coveted (and I’m grateful for some of these offers), a simpler bag is definitely more user friendly and versatile. I also never thought I would be a fan of epsom, but it’s really pretty sturdy lol
They prob do not serve it in mosaic au 24 because they have to be hand washed :smile:
 
  • Insightful
Reactions: LKNN
My Unpopular Opinion is that I am shocked to see sellers of well-loved H bags that are several years old asking for current retail prices or higher. I get that H increases in value and am fine with that, but when a bag has obvious signs of wear and well worn (not in "like new condition"), I think it is insane to demand current retail prices or above for these bags. Then again, this is exactly why these bags do not sell unless they are incredibly rare bags.
 
My Unpopular Opinion is that I am shocked to see sellers of well-loved H bags that are several years old asking for current retail prices or higher. I get that H increases in value and am fine with that, but when a bag has obvious signs of wear and well worn (not in "like new condition"), I think it is insane to demand current retail prices or above for these bags. Then again, this is exactly why these bags do not sell unless they are incredibly rare bags.
any reseller will ask what the market will bear. If they are reselling for someone, it is their duty to their clients who supply them with merchandise to resell at the highest price (not a literal duty but clients will go to a reseller who gets them most $$$ with least commission and they need a supply of bags to continue staying in business). If they are reselling their own items, they might only want to sell if they get over a certain amount and keep otherwise so they are testing the market in a way.
I know you are not using the word "demanding" in it's literal sense but they can demand whatever they want and the buyers will speak with their wallets. For as long as there are buyers for these bags, the prices will remain high. Most of people would say that demanding over $10,000 for any bag is insane, new or not, resale or direct but here we are, eager to drop everything and get to the store when our SA texts us.
To stay on topic, my UO is that mini Evelyn looks like a bag an SA would carry (ducking under my desk from all the mini Evelyns that will be flying at me right now)
 
any reseller will ask what the market will bear. If they are reselling for someone, it is their duty to their clients who supply them with merchandise to resell at the highest price (not a literal duty but clients will go to a reseller who gets them most $$$ with least commission and they need a supply of bags to continue staying in business). If they are reselling their own items, they might only want to sell if they get over a certain amount and keep otherwise so they are testing the market in a way.
I know you are not using the word "demanding" in it's literal sense but they can demand whatever they want and the buyers will speak with their wallets. For as long as there are buyers for these bags, the prices will remain high. Most of people would say that demanding over $10,000 for any bag is insane, new or not, resale or direct but here we are, eager to drop everything and get to the store when our SA texts us.
To stay on topic, my UO is that mini Evelyn looks like a bag an SA would carry (ducking under my desk from all the mini Evelyns that will be flying at me right now)
Oh I get all of that and agree, they can ask for whatever they want. And you are right- they will only get what the market dictates is the market value. The issue is that there aren't always buyers for these bags because of the prices. Many of these well loved bags aren't selling because their prices are too high given their condition, and instead, they just sit on the reseller's websites month after month after month... I suspect that if the prices were more reasonable, they would actually sell.
 
any reseller will ask what the market will bear. If they are reselling for someone, it is their duty to their clients who supply them with merchandise to resell at the highest price (not a literal duty but clients will go to a reseller who gets them most $$$ with least commission and they need a supply of bags to continue staying in business). If they are reselling their own items, they might only want to sell if they get over a certain amount and keep otherwise so they are testing the market in a way.
I know you are not using the word "demanding" in it's literal sense but they can demand whatever they want and the buyers will speak with their wallets. For as long as there are buyers for these bags, the prices will remain high. Most of people would say that demanding over $10,000 for any bag is insane, new or not, resale or direct but here we are, eager to drop everything and get to the store when our SA texts us.
To stay on topic, my UO is that mini Evelyn looks like a bag an SA would carry (ducking under my desk from all the mini Evelyns that will be flying at me right now)
Theres this bag that pops up on the H website sometimes. It could be under the SLG, cant remember. Looks like SA crossbody leather bag. It is gold in color like what the SAs use.
 
Top