What’s your unpopular Hermes opinion?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Those two are my absolute favorite! That period of fashion jewelry, I still dream about. The ceramic pendants they had made with silk tassels in that balcons design were breathtaking. I miss the Isidore and Duncan horn necklaces, too! My (hopefully) not quite unpopular opinion is I miss when Hermes fashion jewelry wasn’t just O’Kelly, amulettes, and clic H designs.

Oh, I'd forgotten about those Balcon pendants! I wish I'd gotten one, I think they were scarce. And, my (possibly unpopular) wish, I keep hoping they'll bring back more gorgeous horn pieces. I agree regarding that era! There were so many beautiful pieces to choose from when I first started shopping at Hermes. You might like this article I posted a while back regarding the craftsmanship required to make the horn and lacquer pieces. :flowers:

https://forum.purseblog.com/threads/ode-to-the-horn.424984/page-177#post-32229884
 
Last edited:
My unpopular opinion is that I actually prefer the mens runway pieces (bags as well as rtw) to the women's.
The designs of the clothes look less 'try-hard' are rely more on the cut and the fabric, they seem 'lighter' somehow.
In women's wear I only really like the outerwear (coats and jackets) but whenever I've tried them they seem to swamp me and where-as I'm not adverse to oversized clothes (I love some pieces by Yhoji,Jil Sander,Old Celine and The Row for instance) every Hermes coat and jacket I've tried just seems to make me look even shorter (I'm 5'3") and just meh....like I'd borrowed them from a taller bigger friend or something.
I SO wanted to buy a leather coat or jacket in the last sale but sadly even going right down to a size 34 (I'm usually size 38) I still looked like some kind of mad monk!
 
My unpopular opinion is that I actually prefer the mens runway pieces (bags as well as rtw) to the women's.
The designs of the clothes look less 'try-hard' are rely more on the cut and the fabric, they seem 'lighter' somehow.
In women's wear I only really like the outerwear (coats and jackets) but whenever I've tried them they seem to swamp me and where-as I'm not adverse to oversized clothes (I love some pieces by Yhoji,Jil Sander,Old Celine and The Row for instance) every Hermes coat and jacket I've tried just seems to make me look even shorter (I'm 5'3") and just meh....like I'd borrowed them from a taller bigger friend or something.
I SO wanted to buy a leather coat or jacket in the last sale but sadly even going right down to a size 34 (I'm usually size 38) I still looked like some kind of mad monk!
ITA. I actually like a lot of RTW for both those genders (when will H do some gender-fluid stuff?) but don't understand how other petite folks fit in any of it. Everything is ginormous on me and not in that "I'm-an-Olsen-in-my-fab-label-The-Row" way, or even the "I'm wearing avant Japanese couture, who cares if it fits" way.....more in the "Give me four tent poles and I can camp out in this" way.
 
ITA. I actually like a lot of RTW for both those genders (when will H do some gender-fluid stuff?) but don't understand how other petite folks fit in any of it. Everything is ginormous on me and not in that "I'm-an-Olsen-in-my-fab-label-The-Row" way, or even the "I'm wearing avant Japanese couture, who cares if it fits" way.....more in the "Give me four tent poles and I can camp out in this" way.
Oh and related unpopular opinion. Why are bags, scarves, etc. divided by gender at Hermès? I see plenty of women wearing men's scarves, bags, jewelry, ties, etc., and plenty of men wearing the items that are assigned as women's. Seems to me that classic designs look great on everyone (including those who identify as non-binary or fluid, as do many tPF members) - why silo anything this way except *maybe* (for sizing mainly) RTW?
 
You could say the same for nearly every H product though.
The materials, design, and craftsmanship are the same, not just similar or arguably equivalent, in the indigenous sources. You can't really say that with authority about other categories of offerings. Plus the "point" or artistic value: who needs H for this, as opposed to its scarves, bags, etc.
 
The materials, design, and craftsmanship are the same, not just similar or arguably equivalent, in the indigenous sources. You can't really say that with authority about other categories of offerings. Plus the "point" or artistic value: who needs H for this, as opposed to its scarves, bags, etc.
Just going to have to agree to disagree. :)
It is an unpopular opinion after all.
 
a wardrobe, like my 2 black CDCs ghw (very retro/Deco over long black sleeves for evening - who needs a new dress?) 1 LFaSdV wide enamel (bought at that time still made in Austria) adds a little boho-chic magic to a 'man's' white shirt, vintage enamel ear clips to pep-up an LBD or severe black, a hand-carved horn Beretta (I love hair ornaments - for Summer / eve up-dos) and a ombre lizard wide 'hinge' bangle (goes with everything). All of these are on the go all the time, even mix and match with fine jewellery.
Agree. unpopular opinion: maybe it’s just me, but I think Hermes is most chic on the youthful or a bit older (I feel I’m still in the middle bc my gray hair isn’t an even salt and pepper lol. One of my style icons is a woman, slim, not too tall, with fabulous salt and pepper gray hair, who was rocking a slightly battered kelly, Levi’s, classic doc martens, crisp white shirt, leather jacket. . . I saw her a few years ago, which actually jump started my love of docs. . . (IMO her style and carriage was similar to @nymeria whose spare and minimal style I admire. And, I personally believe I was most chic in a 90 silk when I was 17 years old, and at least 40 pounds lighter. Lol

Thinking about the latest collaboration Brunello did with Oliver People, I would love to see Hermes make a small collection of sunglasses with an artisan. I’ve seen glasses made of leather or horn, and those are so beautiful.
Agree with this idea. I am a brunello fan. Somehow, the collaboration with OP didn’t work for me, perhaps bc I think the display table of them at the Madison flagship is a bit lacking. I would have preferred Morganthal Frederic for Buffalo horn. or vintage tortoise from Maison Bonnet. Re the glass line themselves, I would take an Hermes glass line more seriously if it was sold exclusively through OP, MF, or MB, the latter of which could be custom fitted by an optometrist. For example, MF carries a line of glasses by Matsuda. matsuda has its own glass line, but the one MF has is a Buffalo horn and sterling pair that is exclusive for MF. Morganthal also carries frames by Cartier, Chrome hearts, Hoffman and others.

ETA: I wish their cotton poplin blouses and other tops, even t shirts, were a bit higher quality. H silk pajama tops with matching bottoms (current collection) are gorgeous, but for the price (I think 3K plus for thr top), they should be able to be shortened (Not possible bc of the pattern)

Turnbull does a lot of custom for my DH, to the point of leaning more fashion, than sartorial (pajama collars, contrast details, turning the pattern on the bias for the pocket or cuffs). The Turnbull product is far more classic than say Etro, but the quality is much better than a fashion house. I’m thinking of selecting silk at Turnbull and having them make custom pajama style tops for me at a fraction of the price.

For more classic shirts, DH favors charvet (MtM with substantial adjustments as Charvet doesn’t think he requires custom). The fit is very different than Turnbull, perhaps more like what Hermes could be. Current H shirt styles, feel like one season fashion pieces, but if they were made like Charvet, they could be for the long haul.

Dior t shirts (mainly cotton with some linen) and many others (including the thin cotton ones from American Giant) have better drape and feel than Hermes. Vintage dead stock rock band t shirts have better material and higher quality graphics. And, chanel t shirts (that I do not own bc they cost a fortune) are super flattering and seem to hide figure flaws, just like their high priced knitwear.
 
Last edited:
Thank you so much @880- coming from you that's quite a compliment!
To stay OT, I'll add my unpopular opinion ( although most of mine have been voiced already)... I think Togo does not take most colors ( especially the darker ones ( noir, VC, etc. ) well. The color usually looks dull to me in that leather.
I will now duck the flying Togo bags ( which will NOT scratch, so there's a plus! :lol: )
 
Thank you so much @880- coming from you that's quite a compliment!
To stay OT, I'll add my unpopular opinion ( although most of mine have been voiced already)... I think Togo does not take most colors ( especially the darker ones ( noir, VC, etc. ) well. The color usually looks dull to me in that leather.
I will now duck the flying Togo bags ( which will NOT scratch, so there's a plus! :lol: )
As your friend, I hope you were able to duck my flying dull Gold K32 in Togo! :lol::biggrin::hugs:
 
I think that the Constance is ugly. Wife still wants to try one on when the boutiques open again. I need to work out a code word with my SA that hides my obvious shaking of my head no.

Not a fan of their brown shades, and this includes Gold. Just looks blah to me.

I think that the Avalon pillows are overstuffed. Not comfortable if behind me where the blankets are great.

Mini bags look ridiculous to me. I get that it’s a trend, but it looks like grown women are going into American Dream stores and walking out with bags minus the dolls.

Someone liked this so it reminded me to update. I lost the fight on the Constance. Wife has two and they’re her favorite bags.
 
Top