I like the look of the vintage but I prefer new. The reason I prefer new is because I like to watch a bag get marks from use. I like to watch it get worn. I usually do not like my bags with a story. I like to create the story.
I like them both. When I saw the new one on the website, I thought nicely done Coach. I do like top stitching though. But there is always the chance to find something like the vintage one poorly listed for $150 obo plus shipping