For me, it depends on the style of the bag. If it’s a bag that I want structure in, I don’t go for Costa Rican leather. I got a Costa Rican Willis and I’m not wild about how floppy it is. But I love my Costa Rican 9136 Legacy Hobos (I have red and mahogany) and my slim duffle.
I have a Mexican rambler’s legacy, which is amazing because it’s soft and molds to my hip well but isn’t too floppy. Then I have a Mexico and a US Prairie and I prefer the stiffness of the US bag in that style.
I have an older US duffle sac and a newer one, but I like the floppiness of the older duffle sac (4-digit, 3-digit creed number) over the newer, more stiff one from ‘94. I like my Dinky’s stiff, so the older the better. And my NYC Rambler is perfect how stiff it is, I wouldn’t want it to be floppy.
There’s a lot that goes into choosing a bag imo!