VCA ~ Van Cleef Arpels Discussion thread!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Thought this was cute (I’m no expert re authenticity or provenance, but this gallery is reputable
 
Thought this was cute (I’m no expert re authenticity or provenance, but this gallery is reputable
Just looking at it I thought it was pretty. Once on, I can see the impact. That’s a really nice piece. What a statement! The blue is amazing.
 
Hi all,
I’m so torn between the two so I’m hoping some of you can tell me your thoughts on both including wear and tear! I feel like I’m leaning more towards the carnelian, but I’m not sure if that’s only because it went well with what I was wearing.
Thank you ◡̈

View attachment 5776079

View attachment 5776080
I like the onyx and YG with your skin tone. Everyone here will tell you both stones are durable. Making these decisions can be so tough!
 
Hi all,
I’m so torn between the two so I’m hoping some of you can tell me your thoughts on both including wear and tear! I feel like I’m leaning more towards the carnelian, but I’m not sure if that’s only because it went well with what I was wearing.
Thank you ◡̈

View attachment 5776079

View attachment 5776080
The onyx looks beautiful on you, a lovely pop of contrast. The carnelian is softer and seems brownish in this photo so personally I prefer the onyx
 
Hi all,
I’m so torn between the two so I’m hoping some of you can tell me your thoughts on both including wear and tear! I feel like I’m leaning more towards the carnelian, but I’m not sure if that’s only because it went well with what I was wearing.
Thank you ◡̈

View attachment 5776079

View attachment 5776080

To me is another case of pop vs. subtle. Which look do you prefer/want? There's no wrong answer here. Both look great on you!

(I agree that this carnelian seems a bit more brown. Still pretty though!)
 
  • Like
Reactions: A bottle of Red
Hi all,
I’m so torn between the two so I’m hoping some of you can tell me your thoughts on both including wear and tear! I feel like I’m leaning more towards the carnelian, but I’m not sure if that’s only because it went well with what I was wearing.
Thank you ◡̈

View attachment 5776079

View attachment 5776080
I prefer the carnelian on you. Imo the shade of carnelian by VCA is quite unique and you can't get it from other brands, whereas onyx you can get it anywhere and will look the same. Do you have a preference on the shade of carnelian? It usually lean from slightly orange, medium neutral red, to dark brownish red. The one you have on appear to be a bit on the darker brown side, I think lighter/brighter shade of red will look even nicer on you :amuse:
 
I prefer the carnelian on you. Imo the shade of carnelian by VCA is quite unique and you can't get it from other brands, whereas onyx you can get it anywhere and will look the same. Do you have a preference on the shade of carnelian? It usually lean from slightly orange, medium neutral red, to dark brownish red. The one you have on appear to be a bit on the darker brown side, I think lighter/brighter shade of red will look even nicer on you :amuse:
Thank you so much! Never in a million years did I think to try carnelian till my SA suggested it and I really do like it. I definitely would prefer the carnelian to not look super brownish red like the one in my photo does.
 
  • Like
Reactions: waterlily112
Top