I agree with the other's above and @BigAkoya's advice....if you want the Pop red, you have to buy a stone that looks orangey/yellow. I had the same experience when shopping for a Magic Pendant a few years ago. The boutique had 4 or 5 and I immediate dismissed the orange one and put on the one's that I like the color while in the tray. Once on, they were too dark and I didn't like them. For kicks, I tried on the orangey one and it was the shade I was seeking when worn.....boy, was I surprised. Here is a picture (unedited) of it on and believe me, if you saw it off, you would immediately pass as I had. It really pops (even against this maroon top!) when worn and often draws random comments.
Good Luck!!
View attachment 5331148
Loooove this shade of Carnelian on you!