i'd get punch. my rule is that my bag is a versatile color: either black, brown, or white. but the stuff inside is all colorful! that makes it so much fun to open my bag and see what is inside. and you already have three black items. i'd get punch for sure. even if you have a brown or white bag, the punch will still stand out. and you'll love it because it's unique. for me, the black agenda is too boring and something everyone has....although i do think the gold turnlock hardware looks better against the black. lol