I have both and love them both! But.... if I had to only pick one... based on my lifestyle and the other bags in my collection, I would pick the Melie. My corners have not been an issue (my first one was and I got it replaced). It's bigger and thus more versatile with the 2 straps I wear mine on the shoulder and crossbody. I can also travel with this as a tote/hobo/crossbody. Lastly the outside zipper pockets are really convenient. Good luck deciding! Maybe do the Berri in monogram and the Melie in empreinte