A belated congrats to both your bags! I totally understand your original dilemma and then keeping both. This happens to be all the time: first I try to choose 1 colour over another so that I have more options (i.e. not 8 brown bags let's say, or not 4 bags all in same design) but inevitably I just want the both or ALL. I do try to avoid getting the same bag in more than one colour but sigh...I am guilty of this.
Speaking of which, it was the saddle/tan Cupid satchel that caught my eye today. The teal & lavender are in stock too. Now I notice that the leather on the lavender is softer, tad finer, distressed and overall, the bag is lighter. The saddle/tan Cupid is almost *almost* pebbled leather, is heavier and the gold hardware is maybe, just maybe a little too shiny for me? So I could get the lavender instead of the saddle/tan but who am I kidding? I really will find an excuse to buy both. Then again, my latest wish list is full of saddle/tan/tobacco coloured bags!? What's girl to do?