Hi! Oh... such drama foir me on coat colors these past days!
First, to answer your question... my black Max Mara is about 5 years, and my camel is about 4 years as I recall.
Both look fine, and most people would not see it. However, I am picky when it comes to detail, and if I really looked at the fabric closely, I can see tiny little fuzzy camel hairs starting to roll up on the fabric. You can see it more on the camel color vs black because it's a lighter shade. To be fair though, I wear my coats in the rain, in the snow, toss them in the plane overhead bin, etc... They get a beating, but these coats are tough and last.
The one thing I do love about the camel color is that you can see the beautiful Max Mara top stitching. I see it so clearly on my camel coat and red coat. The top stitching is lost on my black coat because the fabric is so dark.
On the Saks sale...
After I ordered the black coat, all day, my gut said to me... "another repeat black coat?"


This is because I have been trying to get away from wearing so much black these past two years. Hence, I kept thinking maybe I should have gotten the camel. I love camel coats, so gorgeous, but it's not a coat color I grab regularly.
However, Succession and the quiet luxury theme has influenced me to rethink the camel color.
So...
I decided, this year, I'm going to wear a long camel color coat as part of my rotation! No black! Hence, I ordered the camel too. For sure I will keep the camel as I really want to start wearing this shade. This is especially since I recently purchased a bunch of cashmere sweaters that will work better with a camel coat vs. a black coat.
I am not sure if I will keep the black. I will decide once it arrives and see how "new and fresh" the black looks compared to my current black coat.
One thing I plan to do differently is keep the sleeves long and not shorten them. I'm 5' 2", so in the past, I shortened the sleeves for them to fit like a normal coat. However, I really like the oversized longer sleeve theme that has been on the runways these past few years (it seems everything is oversized, wide, or loose these days). For the red Manuela I bought last year, I decided to kept the sleeves long (e.g. no alterations). I wanted to see how I would like it. I actually loved it, and it worked really well last year with my sweaters.
That was another one of my reasons for buying new coats as I wanted longer sleeve lengths.
Red...
I love love love my red Manuela. A red coat is a neutral, yet the color makes a glamorous and confident statement.
I love it worn casually with a sweater and wide leg jeans.
I hope you try on the red. You never know, you may love it!
To me, a red coat is very different than a red sweater. I don't wear red sweaters, too loud for me against my face and just the top half of my body. That's just me of course.
However, a red long coat is chic and stylish to me, not cha cha cha, if that makes sense and if that's your worry.
Max Mara's red is a nice deep, rich red. Maybe order it while it's still available to see how you like. Red is seasonal, and I am surprised it came back again this year. Maybe it will be a permanent color, who knows.
If you don't think you would wear a red Manuela but want something red, how about a red Adesso?
You mentioned you liked the Adesso, and it comes in red. Although, I must say, there is something about a teddy themed jacket/coat in the classic brown shade, like a fuzzy bear!
Shop Max Mara Adesso Short Alpaca-Blend Jacket at Bergdorf Goodman. Find the latest luxury fashions from top designers.
www.bergdorfgoodman.com