I owned a Tadelakt Kelly which I loved. It came to me pre-loved and was in near perfect shape. It doesn't scratch as easily as Box or Sombrero IMO and has a lovely hand. I would buy another Tadelakt bag no worries - just don't expect it to be either perfect nor indestructible, like any smooth leathers.
ETA: Maybe the mods can fix the typo in the thread title so this thread can be found by search?
ETA: Maybe the mods can fix the typo in the thread title so this thread can be found by search?