Recently my SO has been telling me that he wants to upgrade my tiffany 1.52 ct lucida into a bigger one (2-2.5ct). We went back to Tiffany and I didnt like the 2.2 ct at all, thinking that it looks too big on me( lucida band getting wider as the diamond gets bigger ). I did think the 2.0 ct rectangular lucida is cute though since the band is not as wide. I am not feeling as elated as I should be. Is that normal? Somehow I just think that current one is good enough for me. I know some people say the bigger the better but I am just not sure if that's me. Is it weird to not want a bigger stone? sorry for the rambling, just a little confused that I wasnt that happy about an upgrade. I told my SO that I'll think about it after seeing a few Tiffany rings. TIA for all of your input.