Should I Keep Both, One, or Neither of These Bargain Bags? Reveal!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I have the zebra E/W tote and it's a GREAT travel bag! I got mine at the outlets a few months ago for $119 I think? I've used it on all my trips since then since I'm not worried about it getting dirty. All of my other Coach bags are leather so I'm always paranoid about them scratching, etc but for the price and the fabric, I don't really care on this bag.

I would keep the zebra if you can only keep one but they're both beautiful. I'm jealous of the red patent!


That's how I feel about it! I can enjoy the zebra print tote - especially as a travel bag - but not have to worry about it. It seems resilient and it was inexpensive and it looks good!


I bought one of those MFF signature packable nylon travel bags that Coach has been selling and I returned it. It was just kind of flimsy and blah IMO - besides the "puddle problem." But the zebra print is lightweight but tough and stylish.
 
I'd keep both. I have the same crimson tote and I love it. Actually have a few of them in different colors.
I have the N/S but in chenille ocelot and it's great bag. So roomy and so light weight.


Thanks! Is the zipper a problem with the patent tote? It seems like you need 2 hands to close the breakaway zippers.


The ocelot tote is beautiful too, thanks again!
 
I agree with other poster and would keep both . Plus the prices are too good to pass on.
I don't own any patent bags but that red would definitely go home with me.
Gorgeous for the winter holiday season.
I do have the zebra print on a swing pack. Loved the print so much , had to buy something with it !;) ENJOY your lovelies !!!
 
I like the zebra one much better, so I would kept that one.
But if it is not love I would return both as there always will be many bags to come by at low prices. The worst thing is to end up with large collection of not loves.
 
Both are gorgeous! And at great prices!
I have the zebra e/w tote, and I really wish i got the n/s or phoebe in that print. the fabric is soooo nice.
I have the diagonal pleated tote that has the breakaway zipper. I just don't zip open all the way to the end, so it's easier to zip close with 1 hand.
 
I agree with other poster and would keep both . Plus the prices are too good to pass on.
I don't own any patent bags but that red would definitely go home with me.
Gorgeous for the winter holiday season.
I do have the zebra print on a swing pack. Loved the print so much , had to buy something with it !;) ENJOY your lovelies !!!

Thanks! I am surprised that I liked an animal print fabric bag but that one has a great look! It would be so light weight in a swing pack, good choice!
 
I like the zebra one much better, so I would kept that one.
But if it is not love I would return both as there always will be many bags to come by at low prices. The worst thing is to end up with large collection of not loves.

Wise words! I have made poor bag choices on impulse in the past - usually because it was a great deal. That's why I am determined to try these out a bit at home first before cutting the tags.

I will see how they feel on my shoulder and decide if the puddling is too much of a big problem or if I can't stand the breakaway zipper.

Even though they were a great price, $100 is still real money and I don't need a closet stuffed full of bags that I don't wear!

I am pretty sure that the zebra print will be a winner but the jury is still out on the red patent tote. Thanks!
 
Both are gorgeous! And at great prices!
I have the zebra e/w tote, and I really wish i got the n/s or phoebe in that print. the fabric is soooo nice.
I have the diagonal pleated tote that has the breakaway zipper. I just don't zip open all the way to the end, so it's easier to zip close with 1 hand.

Thanks, I will try that with the zipper. They had zebra print phoebes in clearance at the outlet yesterday. I'm thinking that they were also $99 but I am not sure about that.
 
Thanks! Is the zipper a problem with the patent tote? It seems like you need 2 hands to close the breakaway zippers.


The ocelot tote is beautiful too, thanks again!


Not really, since the bag is big enough that you don't have to open it all the way to take something out. I have that problem with the mini tanner, where the zipper breaks apart every time I get my wallet out and I hate it but love the functionality of the mini tanner, so I just deal with it. With the tote, you won't have this problem. Try it a little bit around the house. Put your stuff in and pretend a few times that you need to open it to get something out of it. That would give you an idea of the behavior.


What I like about this tote is the size, straps are the perfect length, is so lightweight and because of the patent leather, perfect for even rainy days. Ah, and don't forget the color. Love the crimson color! Patent crimson was the first one I got.


I'm thinking now of switching into my patent ultramarine.
 
I have the madison tote in persimmon, black, and the purple patent (don't remember the exact Coach name for the color)...and I love all three. I am not a fan of the zebra - my outlet had several of the Kelsey zebras last week - I love Kelsey but just couldn't pull the trigger because of the print. So my vote is Madison patent...I think you live in the Chicago area?, think about how awesome that crimson tote would make you feel on a cold, snowy day! I am in NH so I know how it would make me feel!
 
Not really, since the bag is big enough that you don't have to open it all the way to take something out. I have that problem with the mini tanner, where the zipper breaks apart every time I get my wallet out and I hate it but love the functionality of the mini tanner, so I just deal with it. With the tote, you won't have this problem. Try it a little bit around the house. Put your stuff in and pretend a few times that you need to open it to get something out of it. That would give you an idea of the behavior.


What I like about this tote is the size, straps are the perfect length, is so lightweight and because of the patent leather, perfect for even rainy days. Ah, and don't forget the color. Love the crimson color! Patent crimson was the first one I got.


I'm thinking now of switching into my patent ultramarine.

I have the red and love it! Place a safety pin on the zipper and it won't come undone. Love it!!


Thanks! Since I take public transportation and work in the city it is important that I can easily and securely close my bags.
 
Top