Sad realization...

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I understand what you mean.

One of the hard things about engagement rings is the feeling like you are going to have it forever, so you better pick right!

Sometimes we become infatuated with a certain idea, because we think that the item or thing we want will "complete" us, and we won't be complete with out it. When we get infatuated, we can only see the positives, and not the negatives, and our perceptions can get unbalanced. In reality, everything has positives and negatives, and nothing is perfect, it just is. Try thinking of some negatives of your dream ring.

For instance:

- Boring
- New, not antique (lacks history and character)
- A trophy object, rather than a sigh of true love

Sure, most of us would all love the big rock to prove that we are a princess in a fairytale, but at the end of the day this is just one dream that we buy into, and there are heaps of other versions of reality. A more modest, antique ruby and diamond cluster might show a little more character and personality, and might in the end be more "you" than an ideal to which you are trying to live up to.

It depends on the person you are. You need to consider what your values really are. If they include a little bit more glitz and glamour than your husband, you need to consider that that is the person who you are. You need to deside how much of yourself you are willing to sacrifice for love. At the end of the day - "I y'am what I y'am"! Don't compromise, if that is your true ideal.

There is a saying - the poor man buys twice - meaning that if you don't get what you want to start with, you will spend twice as much money down the track when you go back to buy what you wanted in the first place.

Another thing - if it is really important, tell your fiance that you want it for your 5th or 10th anniversary, and save up for it as a replacement. How exciting!
 
Tiffany's is a brand that has spent millions on clever marketing - that's it. They're really nothing special....most of the e-ring designs seem terribly boring to me - and if we're seeking to be 'special' by having an 'exclusive' brand....how special is it really to have a ring from what is essentially a multinational corporation?!

I'm surprised the Tiffany mystique is still so intact for many gals. Whenever I think of Tiffany, all I can think of is the sterling silver jewelry. It's like the beautiful Schlumberger designs and all else that truly distinguishes the brand has gone out of my mind with the proliferation of the sterling silver.

Tiffany doesn't strike me as a prestige brand anymore, and you're right, the primary attribute that sets diamonds apart from one another is how they're marketed by Cartier, Winston, etc. It really is buying into a dream pre-dreamt for you by a clever marketing person. So it should be nothing to feel angst over.
 
Last edited:
OP, don't feel bad, you can find a beautiful ring in your price range at another store that will glitter like a Tiffanys! Also, keep in mind that the expectations put on engagement rings these days is really a new phenomenon. It seems like anything under 1 KT these days is qualified as small (and sometimes 1KT is considered too small, only 2 KT will do!), but a generation ago this wasn't the case. There's not only the Tiffany's mystique to contend with, but that your guy show that he has the spending power of a small nation when buying your ring. Ignore both expectations - they are ludicrous. I know if you start looking around at more reasonably priced rings, you'll find another perfect ring for you. I think you would also be surprised how many women here on the engagement ring thread have upgraded their original rings as they have become more financially savvy and successful. Relatively few guys just starting their careers have the money to buy a Tiffany engagement ring, no matter what that career may be.
 
i read a lovely thing about diamond 'flaws' ... someone called them 'birth marks' which i love! having said that i wouldnt go below an SI1 ... My diamond is SI1 but eye clean.
But seriously - i think u find out your budget and go from there.
 
Coming from someone who has gone through this stage...the ring seems very important at the stage you are at, but as you travel through time your viewpoint will change a little. It is lovely to have this dream ring, but you will see other things are much more important.
Why don't you consider a different ring from Tiffanys, but still a gorgeous ring?
How about a Celebration Ring?
http://www.tiffany.com/Shopping/Category.aspx?cid=287462&mcat=148210
Choose one in your price point that will make the both of you happy and not cripple your finances. It will still sparkle like crazy and you will feel great that it is from Tiffanys as that is your dream.
Then, as a few years pass and your finances change you can either add another band and stack them or possibly purchase your solitaire you now have your eyes on.
There are no rules on how to do it. Choose what makes you happy. Some women only have one ring and some have many.
Best of Luck!
Congratulations, you have someone who loves you!!!

Words of wisdom here:tup:.
 
I laugh at the bolded part, because other than tPF and maybe the PS forum or something, nobody I know EVER talks about the brand of the ring, the specs, etc. In the real world, VERY VERY VERY few people actually care about these things. Or at least that's been my personal experience. And until I got engaged, I didn't care either. Other than, "Oooh, my ring is pretty!" I still really don't care, and it doesn't matter to me how other people's rings look or where they came from or anything like that. When you get down to it, a lot of this stuff is pretty much meaningless.

wow, i think i'd you'd be able to knock some common sense into me any day.
 
Ok, now that you seem to be over the Tiffany thing, you need to get educated before you buy. Your money will go sooo much further. DON'T buy from a mall or that Tustin place. First, go to Pricescope.com or Goodoldgold.com and do your homework. DO NOT buy and I2 or I3. They will have visible imperfections. The MOST important thing is the cut. (Not the shape). First, check out Blue Nile. Good Old Gold is also an excellent online retailer. They have a great tutorial on their website that is easy to understand. I hate to see people on a budget blow their money and get less than they could get for the same amount. If you call them at Good Old Gold, they can tell you if the stone you want is eyeclean or not. (This is the term meaning you don't see the imperfections with the naked eye. You can get an eyeclean SI1 or even SI2 but it would be harder. I would aim for an SI1. Don't be in a hurry to get something. This is one of the most important things you will ever buy.
 
Are you in love with the Tiffany brandname, diamond, or their setting? If it's the setting you want, the solution is simple. You can buy a nice diamond in your price range thru Pricescope or any reputable jeweler and have it set in a Tiffany-style setting.

In my 40s now. I too came to the realization that my dh is not going to afford upgrades or anniversary rings. I'd always wanted a platinum cathedral airline setting with a sizeable princess stone upgrade. So I chose the best possible approach and that was to work with what I was able to at this time. I carefully chose an affordable Palladium setting which I adored, and had a high quality diamond simulant set into it. I absolutely love it.

At my age, whether it came from a small jeweler or high end place didn't matter. I made it happen to the best of my ability in my circumstance. Women should never feel it's all or nothing and that their sense of happiness is based only on the unattainable. It's important to create your own happiness by making it happen with whatever is within your reach. :idea:
 
Last edited:
I would rather have a big good quality diamond than a small mediocre grade designer e ring

Some of us girls that do have Tiffany e-rings have the opposite argument: we'd much rather have a small, good quality ring than a big mediocre one (quality over quantity) :p

To the OP: I think a lot of the girls have offered you some really good advice here and when you seriously start shopping for a ring, take yourself over to pricescope.com and do your research before you commit. And trust me, when your fiance proposes and his ring on your finger, you won't care if it's designer brand or not.
 
I understand what you mean.

One of the hard things about engagement rings is the feeling like you are going to have it forever, so you better pick right!

Sometimes we become infatuated with a certain idea, because we think that the item or thing we want will "complete" us, and we won't be complete with out it. When we get infatuated, we can only see the positives, and not the negatives, and our perceptions can get unbalanced. In reality, everything has positives and negatives, and nothing is perfect, it just is. Try thinking of some negatives of your dream ring.

For instance:

- Boring
- New, not antique (lacks history and character)
- A trophy object, rather than a sigh of true love

Sure, most of us would all love the big rock to prove that we are a princess in a fairytale, but at the end of the day this is just one dream that we buy into, and there are heaps of other versions of reality. A more modest, antique ruby and diamond cluster might show a little more character and personality, and might in the end be more "you" than an ideal to which you are trying to live up to.

It depends on the person you are. You need to consider what your values really are. If they include a little bit more glitz and glamour than your husband, you need to consider that that is the person who you are. You need to deside how much of yourself you are willing to sacrifice for love. At the end of the day - "I y'am what I y'am"! Don't compromise, if that is your true ideal.

There is a saying - the poor man buys twice - meaning that if you don't get what you want to start with, you will spend twice as much money down the track when you go back to buy what you wanted in the first place.

Another thing - if it is really important, tell your fiance that you want it for your 5th or 10th anniversary, and save up for it as a replacement. How exciting!

I love what u wrote thank you... I like the fact that we can earn that big ring. If we make it that it... I love that idea. Thank you.:yes:
 
Thanks ladies for all your comments, tips, and advice. I am going to keep looking for that ring, but what if he buys my ring and its not a clean diamond. Should I just keep quiet? I know I am going to love it, the fact that he is proposing, but what if he gets me a really bad ring?
 
why dont you explain that you've read so much online about getting the best possible value and you'd love to share that with him? i cant imagine any guy wanting to spend a fortune on a crap ring??
 
AlbertsLove! Look at OVERSTOCK.COM! They have GREAT diamond rings...

I just found this one:

http://www.overstock.com/Jewelry-Wa...d-Engagement-Ring-I-J-I1/1980574/product.html

There is a 5% coupon code discount just for clicking on the site and if you type "overstock.com coupon code" into a Google window, you can find coupons for up to 20% off.

Seriously. They have tons of beautiful rings, good quality diamonds and are in your price range. The one I posted is $764.09 with the 5% coupon, but it might be less, and that one is 3/4 of a carat total weight and IJ I1.

Bluenile.com has a 1/2 carat 3 stone ring I/SI2 for 1200 and you can probably find at least a 10% off coupon online for them as well.

http://www.bluenile.com/diamond-ring-white-gold_5773?nav1=jewelry_segment.jsp

DO NOT BE AFRAID TO BARGAIN RIGHT NOW

Jewelers are hurting too and they need your business.

I'm with the other gals on this one. Tiffany's has a great brand image, but you will get a better quality ring, for much less cost outside of them.

Take 10 years and save up! For your 10 Year anniversary, get the "celebration ring"!

So nice that you found a good man. Hang onto him!
 
Some of us girls that do have Tiffany e-rings have the opposite argument: we'd much rather have a small, good quality ring than a big mediocre one (quality over quantity) :p

To the OP: I think a lot of the girls have offered you some really good advice here and when you seriously start shopping for a ring, take yourself over to pricescope.com and do your research before you commit. And trust me, when your fiance proposes and his ring on your finger, you won't care if it's designer brand or not.

I wholeheartedly agree. Truer words have never been spoken.
 
Top