I had the reverse outcome. I had a fabric coach that completely fell apart on me in about a year. (Bought in 2009 or 2010) I've had one of my speedy for almost 7 years and it looks amazing. It has seen me thru my mid 20's into my early 30s and I plan on being 90 and still carry one. (Hopefully the ones I own now) Part of the reason I am drawn to the speedy is the simplicity and what little leather there is on it. I have 2 speedies (30 mono & DE) and am planning on getting a 30 in DA before the redesign so I am a bit of a speedy lover.