No doubt I don’t speak for everyone but what I’m seeing is as follows:
A couple years ago,
Polene really hit a high note, at least here on TPF. Many of us were super impressed with the design aesthetic for the price point, which seemed generally also to have decent quality. Albeit there were always some hit or misses.
In the last year — IMO an uptick in stories of subpar quality, and unpleasant customer service. A lack of new colorways in the designs that won popularity amongst us initially.
Then in the last few months, a major rebranding, with a focus I think on diversifying their offerings i.e. now - Jewelry. More wallets. Misc items. Etc. This broadening of goods may have caused quality to suffer.
At a high level it makes sense for a company to diversify to grow, and maybe with their new approach they are growing amongst customers more quickly in other ways. For my part I’m just massively less interested. If they could offer newer types of items at the same rate as iterating on new handbags and maintaining the same quality, I might care - as it is I’m bored and unimpressed and I don’t. I suspect I’m not alone either, as the rate of new posts to this thread has declined significantly.
I don’t mean any of the above to detract from anyone who is still enjoying Polene’s goods. I have three bags from them that I still like and use. I’m just sharing what my opinion on the general trend is, given that I’ve continued to check in on this thread over the past few months.