Please help me decide which Peyton to keep

[puckettk]

I adore the Gray... If I wasn't so banned I would be running to the outlets for one myself!!

 

[wifeyb]

MAFIA!!!! im glad you made your decision! i think youll be happy with the grey.

 

[kphillips]

DEFINITELY keep the grey patent - I would return the the other two. Unless money isn't really an object, then I'd also keep the atlantic b/c it really is a fun bag! But I also agree that if it's been in your closet that long, it's probably time to return it!

Edit: I posted before I read your entire thread! Glad you decided to keep the grey, I think it is so beautiful! And probably a good choice to return the atlantic!

 

[mafiamom]

Thanks again for all the replies. I returned the atlantic peyton this morning to the San Marcos outlet. They had peytons in white, dark green, metallic, shimmery green (whatever that is called), atlantic and gunmetal. The gunmetal is beautiful, but was afraid that I might have problems with the color coming off. Also, some editorial zoes and some with the braided handles in gray and cream color.