@Cygne18 @Pautinka @cavalla @Joannadyne @Croisette7 @Mme. de la Paix @lanit @katriona @calexandre @orchard @hopiko @Ladybaga @ms piggy @smallfry @litchi @papertiger Thank you all for your comforting words.

I made an attempt to exchange for another in store today. (I had called yesterday late afternoon to check which store has availability if any.) This store had 2 in stock and after the SA returned from the stock room to show me the shawl, I mentioned that I would be doing an exchange because of the flaw - red dot sticker and stain. I was told flat out that an exchange isn't possible and that I have to send the shawl back to the online site and they would give me a refund in a snooty manner.
Well, I could've bought that pristine shawl that I'd just inspected but I'm not buying with crap service. I rather wait (im)patiently for my store to get it instead. (I had also witnessed another SA being snooty to two customers who asked to see the Evelyn in display case and was told "no stock today" with a sullen look on her face while I waited for the SA to return from the stockroom.

)
I also called H.com customer service to inform them of my faulty shawls and was told that they would be contacting me on Monday to resolve the issue. Well, in the meantime I'm sending both shawls back

I will also be writing a complaint but am wondering who do I direct to as I want someone at corporate H to know that "Hey customers notice that we're slacking!"
@Croisette7 Thank you for sharing that you had encountered a similar experience with a red sticker on the silk. I think this is a supply chain issue and not an issue with the online store. Someone is slacking on their job and I too, like
@ms piggy think that H are having production issues.
@smallfry If you compare this season to the previous one, there's less CSGM designs as is. Something doesn't add up...
@Sickgrl13 I'm sorry you're finding flaws in your 03 shawl as well.

I hope you're able to find another that's flawless.