Well, if I get one, it will be pre-loved, and I prefer retourne, especially in this very casual leather. I'm not even going to try to get a new one -- somehow with box and barenia, I think I'll be more comfortable with some patina already in place!
Ladies you are presenting some difficulties here. You really have to love the leather. It is something else. So thick and firm, so strong feeling. Waxy and velvety at the same time. I can't imagine a cooler Kelly
catsinthebag. In my opinion, she would be cool and a statement--but I don't see "casual," I see stinkin' cool/chic--confident.
bjostone, I am thinking about others in and out of your Birkin and worry about their nails, keys, whatever. I am careful with mine but the tucked in flap has taken a bit more than other parts. But again, maybe the preloved is the key?
I wonder how long a Barenia has to be carried to be "preloved?" Mine is almost a year old and I have carried her cumulatively maybe 6 months and she still looks brand new to me.
Any insight from others?
My point is, if the bag is 5 years, preloved, is she then "weathered" against scratches in a way that will make her a perfect choice for you girls? Such decisions....