Neither. You have a lot of black and need a light color bag for summer and spring. Contrary to some who believe that "black goes with everything", it really does not go with light or bright summer clothes. If you only had one black Chanel, it's ok to wear all year but you have several Chanels so why keep buying "safe" black? This is about fashion and honestly, wearing a black bag with light summer clothes is not a chic fashionable look.
How about beige Claire? It's gorgeous. I would not buy yet another black or dark bag. I would get Beige Claire, white or some bright or light color for warm weather.
Just my two cents.