Candace, not trying to make a Carryall believer out of you but I want to reply.
1. The microfiber lining does contribute to weight no doubt but what a wonderful luxurious feel when reaching in your bag! The PM weighs 1 lb 4 ounces and I don’t think that is heavy at all. The MM on the other hand I found inordinately heavy.
The name "Carryall" to me implied it could carry all… and for me the PM certainly carries my daily essentials. And the huge MM would certain carry all essentials and work stuff. The Neverfull MM in canvas could do the job lighter for sure.
2. Carrying crossbody works great on my 5’1” frame although I don’t see myself doing that very often. So if one wishes crossbody than another option might be a better choice.
3. I am not sure what folding in and creasing you experienced but I have not been able to recreate it.
4. Wow and I handled three Carryalls and all were flawless. I am surprised your boutique would have even had bags with such flaws on their sales floor.
Of course I have to leave you with another photo is my pretty! ❤️
View attachment 5643729