Need Help Picking between 2 bags! Pics!

keep the bev, and return the other. i agree that they are very similar. maybe you could exchange for a black or white riveting if you really love the style and size?
 
Gorgeous pics!

The beverly looks perfect on you...however, the riveting is more eye-catching and I'm sure the leather will soften up with time to suit your body more....I'd say keep the riveting!