Thanks for the votes everyone! I've decided on the Cole Hann in black for sure. I also just got a notice about the BillionDollarBabes Tate sale. I couldn't resist the Palmer Tote and also found an extra $25 off coupon. I've heard amazing things about Tate bags. Can't wait to get it and the Cole Hann in the mail.
Great choices! Cole Haan makes great bags and I've heard good things about Kale too. Enjoy your purchases!