I would keep the chocolat and sell one of the other paddys
Oh your chocolate is SO gorgeous..the leather is amazing! I had a '05 whiskey paddy but sold it to a tpf member b/c my dog needed surgery and I've been seriously thinking now about getting a black paddy! I love how gorgeous the leather on yours is and from what I understand the quality has been fluctuating so much as of late. So....if you went to grab this bag one day and realized you sold it for an (equally luscious) b-bag would you regret it?? Would you miss it? I would maybe wait a bit..carry her for a few days and see how you feel. Bored? Ready for a change? Too in love to part with ? You might not get that quality again now if you decide to re-buy her later on . Tough choice..good luck! LOVE your collection!
My first instinct is to say KEEP the Chocolate at all costs (and I voted accordingly). But if you are really itching for a balenciaga, then the chocolate will be an easy sell. I would just hate to see you get rid of it though because it is so absolutely gorgeous! No one does chocolate like Chloe. Just follow your heart- if you are really falling in love with b-bags (which I adore) then go for it. Sell the choco (cannot believe I just said that- sac relig) and use it towards a bag that you love!
So, what color b-bag are you thinking of getting?