def. the bowler!! i have the white bowler and i love it. yes it does get a little dirty but thats just something you have to accept when you have a white bag. I decided to get it in white because it really is one of the nicest white bags i've seen. I was really debating on the black or white bowler..or the black or white flap. I think the white white bowler is perfect because it really isn't meant for an everyday bag cause the material is a little softer than the flap bag. I knew that if i got the bowler in black i would use it a lot more. If you want an everyday bag i think the flap black is good but the white bowler is gorgeous. I got it the day after thanksgiving and right when i saw it I fell in love. Plus i think the bowler looks what its worth.