OMG so i go to pick up the large sig stripe tote, but its not what i wanted. I always wanted the shoulder tote!! I went to 14th street later on to return it and see what they might have. I went and tried on the leather carly in red and was about to buy it but they had a sig stripe demi in punch!!! of course i bought it!! this is supposed to be sold out! she said it was hiding in the back or something and then i go to macys and get the shoulder tote! i couldnt stand it!! i really really really wanted it and now i have it!! this solves my carly dilemma.. because it is very similar to the carly style (shoulder and strap wise), if they had a carly in stiff denim fabric, I would have gotten it!! you guys are right the red leather carly and the chocolate carly are to die for!! but shoulder tote stays with me!!! ok i ll take better pics tomorrow i m at my sisters!