Hello ,
I would like to share my experience about buying Loewe bags pre-loved and using online authentication services. Last year I have bought several Loewe bags via platform called Vinted. It is a second hand market that offers buyers protection. This platform at first did not offer authentication services and so for my first bag I have used authentication service calle ****************** - they were quick and relatively cheap and I bought their authenticity certificate. They confirmed the bag was authentic. When I tried to re-sel the bag on platform called Vestiare collective , I provided them with said certificate , they told me the bag failed physical authentication.
Learning from this experience for the purchase of my other bag via the Vinted platform I have used different authenticator called Legit grails , again I got authenticity certificate. Few months later I tried to sell it on the same platform I bought it which is Vinted and they started providing authentication service which the person buying the bag from me used. This bag too failed physical authentication. I was gutted.
After this I reached out to another online authenticator called Legit checks this company is expensive I have paid about 100eur for it but they provided certificate specifically explaining why the bag is fake and who it is not complaint. My credit card company accepted this report and reimbursed me.
Please note I have also used Vinted paid authentication services when purchasing another Loewe bag and when I send it to Vestiare collective they said the bag was fake.
In summary I have used 4 different authentication services in the last 6 months for Loewe purchases. It appears that 3 of them authenticated bags which later failed authentications elsewhere. Not being expert myself I can not say it those bags are real of fake, and thus I can not say who is wrong, but I no longer trust the authentication process.
I don’t understand this world of authentications how can someone say it’s authentic and some its fake. I have gone back to the authenticators who confirmed authenticity and they explained that it is normal that authenticators disagree , they also said the database they use to check the photos also sometimes disagrees with itself. They also said it is good to ask for 2nd or even 3rd opinion when purchasing pre-loved.
Does anybody else have similar experience using different authentication services.
I am not sure if authentication has become so much more commercialised these days or is this just Loewe because as a brand they only recently become popular enough to be faked.
But I was forced to paying for one due to the absolute lack of knowledge in forums that are usually the bastion of luxury brand knowledge like this forum for example.
Like you, I quickly realise the pitfalls of paid authentication services. They have their uses of course.
The pitfalls are
(1) They are simply people's OPINIONS.
(2) Over reliance of paid authentications by buyers (myself included) - This is especially true when we as buyers don't know what we are looking at.
(3) The lack of standardised commercial practice of what "authenticating" really entails - This resulted in opinions that might as well be random and there is no way of telling if they are not.
(4) The extensive knowledge of a brand someone must have that takes constant study for new updates to be someone who can really authenticate something. - This takes a lot of time and "training" someone to be a good authenticator of a particular brand is a crap shoot at best it seems.
(5) The harm these do to resellers who genuinely sell authentic items
This is why a highly regarded Hermes authenticator only work with Hermes and nothing else. They call their authentication process an "observation". Because technically that is all they can do. Certificate of Observation is what they issue. Not Certificate of Authenticity. Which if we think about it, only the creators of the products can issue.
But Loewe did not even have its own subforum here until recently.
Authenticating Loewe is truly a nightmare in itself that I have decided NOT to buy preowned ever again. Unless I am absolutely certain about what I am looking at. Such as the first generation puzzle bag from circa 2016-2017 I just bought from a reseller.
I wont even bother authenticating.
When, or IF, I resell this bag, I can already see the nightmare of proofing that the bag is authentic to buyers who do not necessarily know what an authentic Loewe looks or feels like, and who are heavily relying on paid authenticators to tell them so.