You have mentioned the jewellery pieces (and collection) that I LOVE!I absolutely love (and mostly only like) the chunky and statement jewelry. My favorite gold piece is the large full Parade bracelet in rose gold that was especially made for me. My favorite necklace is my silver tie Etcetera, which I don’t wear too often due to it being 500+ grams, but thoroughly love seeing it in its gigantic box. Years ago, my Paris SA surprised me with the silver meteorite medor géante ring that is a 2cmx2cmx2cm cube with a medor on each side. Not for everyone, but I absolutely love it as a cocktail ring.
The last jewelry collection that I truly liked was the Punk Chaine d’Ancre collection. Paris had shown and offered me some of the larger pieces nearly a year before it was offered in the US. This now feels distant. Their new releases and majority of product line is simply too dainty. I tried and bought a few over the years of the newer and daintier gold jewelry, but they have all gone to Fashionphile. Hermes has fully embraced the small and “cheaper” prespend bait. I remember when my SA showed me a pair of those diamonds finesse earrings. The funniest part is that my SA was trying to sell me those and costed only around $4k then. Now, Fashionphile is flooded with them, and they cost $8.5k!
I think we have similar Hermes preferences as I, too, adore rtw under JPG and Margiela. I am currently trying to find that shearling stole with the pockets. I remember back when Hermes released the quick sneakers under Margiela that was the it sneaker. I still love my pairs! I also miss the clochette necklace of that time especially the exotic ones. That was a great moment in Hermes history that I find is lost currently; at least, I struggle to find.
The Medor géante ring?? OMG

Yes we obviously share the same aesthetic in rtw and jewellery.
I am lucky enough to own two of the clochette necklaces but the matt black croc one is a thing of beauty indeed! (and sadly not in my possession)
I think 'pre-spend bait' is a perfect description for much of the jewellery and rtw offerings available in the stores presently.
Ditto the shoe offerings ...too many lazy variations on the oran for instance.
Anyway I daresay this should go into unpopular opinions.
but to go back on topic I'll be done with Hermes when all the pre-loved discontinued designs I love are no longer available to find or so prohibitively expensive that purchasing them is no longer an option.
I will also be done with Hermes when all they produce is logo'd or more car-crash reiterations of the holy trinity of bags.
I'll be done with Hermes when they do not have a single item in their stores that appeals to me.