I think Saddle or Lipstick/Saddle. Saddle is the best choice as most versatile. I have the Saddle Oxford and it is very neutral. It was at Off 5th, so you may be able to find one floating around out there. If not, E-bay probably is your best bet. I think you will be happy with it. I tend to wear warm shades, too. Saddle is the perfect complement to them.