Is it wrong to leave Neutral Feedback?

mdlcal28

O.G.
Feb 1, 2008
1,488
4
Won an item on 7/1/12...
Paid for item on 7/5/12...
Paid for Priority Shipping...
Item coming from west coast to southeast
Received item today.....
Item was great, very happy with it.........
But 15 days?
May have been the seller, may have been the post office, but I have no way to verify which. Seller said on 7/14 that it had already been shipped....
 

Phred

Member
Nov 28, 2009
106
2
are you happy with the item? THAT is your feedback. The stars reflect specific 'happy happy'. I'd also leave FB like "won 7/1, pd 7/5, shipped 7/12"

Also, what does the seller's shipping terms state? any specific day they ship or time frame that they ship?
 
Sep 1, 2009
2,569
2,125
Well, I have in my terms, 4 business days for handling; never use that much, but just in case. So, in my case, counting the weekend in there......

You waited 4 days to pay, she shipped in 4 or 5 business days, then right? Was it paid in the evening?
I cannot get too excited about sellers taking a few days to ship, but that is me.
 

IrisCole

O.G.
Dec 28, 2007
9,245
51
Well, I have in my terms, 4 business days for handling; never use that much, but just in case. So, in my case, counting the weekend in there......

You waited 4 days to pay, she shipped in 4 or 5 business days, then right? Was it paid in the evening?
I cannot get too excited about sellers taking a few days to ship, but that is me.

Agreed. If you took a few days to pay, she may have also taken a few days to ship, and then there's a weekend in there as well. If you're happy with the item, I would probably not leave neutral for this.
 

MAGJES

O.G.
Dec 13, 2008
25,776
46,687
The printed label said 7/12/12.
She may have printed the label on 7-12-12 but if you didn't receive until today (20th) then she probably didn't deliver it to the post office until well after the 12th. It doesn't normally take a week for Priority Mail to be deliveried. Of course there still is the chance that UPSP is at fault .......sorry - not much help but I wouldn't leave a neutral but might mention the delay in the positive feedback.

Paid on the 5th - Thursday
She printed a label an entire week later - Thursday - 12th.
If you received on the 20th then she didn't take it to the post office until
proabably the next Tuesday.... the 17th - you received on the 20th. My opinion - that's quite slow.
 

tutushopper

❤️ Lambskin Lover ❤️
O.G.
Apr 13, 2012
16,417
130
I agree with the above; I've had shippers take a week to ship things (I take one day when I sell), but if I am happy with the item, then I'm happy with the item. I am not so thrilled they took so long to ship the item, but if I'm that unhappy about that, I could leave a star or two less on shipping time, not on the rest. Usually, when I open the item, I'm happy about the item and forget how long it took them to ship.

ETA: shipping time meaning how long between when I paid (usually right away) and when they take the item to the post office
 
Sep 1, 2009
2,569
2,125
If the seller shipped on the 12th, I do not think she should be dinged or anything. The buyer took their sweet time to pay (4 days-just enough for no npb to be filed). If you are happy with the item, then I would leave a positive and maybe not even rate the shipping stars.
JMHO, as always
 
Top