I would say get the ones in better condition.. If it were me. I would hate to receive the ones that are not as new and nit-pick over the flaws and kick myself for not spending the extra money for the better ones. I recently purchased a Klara off ebay and there are a few dings on the long strip of leather across the face of the bag.. and let me tell you, even though I totally the bag, everytime I see the dings, I just *sigh* inside and mentally kick myself for not buying a new one when I held it IN MY HAND at the store back in January of this year!!! I'm even debating on going to Louis Vuitton to see how much it would cost to replace those 2 strips!!