Thanks for the responses everyone!! I really appreciate it! I'm still torn on whether I should get one or not just because I don't even wear any of my Tiffany pieces anymore... However, I do like DY pieces. I've gone in and tried several pieces and do love how classic and timeless thy look. I like how it feels more substantial and seems to fit a more "mature" demographic versus my Tiffany pieces. But 500-700$ is definitely something to think about!!
I'm thinking between these two pieces... What do you all think? Should I try and buy from eBay or buy brand new for my first piece?
I would definitely go the eBay route (as long as you know it is authentic) because should you sell it you already bought it at a discounted price so it should not be as hard to recoup your money tied up in it.