I have both, and I use the Halzan more due to versatility. With an Indigo Barenia Evelyne, it is soft and great for super casual trips to the market, work or shopping. The older Eveynes had a narrower strap and it is more comfortable than the newer models with all the hardware. Plus my strap was custom made to wear cross body. My barenia Halzan is beautiful. People stop me on the street to ask about it. I carry it tote style for work and meetings. When traveling it really is great for cross body wear. I am five feet five and it just fits, though would be nice if it was maybe one inch longer. It has been a good investment for me, and knowing barenia, it will age in time to eventually get deeper and richer as well as softer. For me having a heritage leather is the ultimate joy!