I have a vintage 35 kelly that I have decided I don't need and will sell. But the handle is dry and has just recently come apart from the bag. I have some questions and wonder if anyone can help...
How much is it currently to replace the handle?
Is it better to replace the handle than to sell, or should I sell and let the buyer sort out the handle? I would rather just sell the bag as is, but if I am going to recoup the value of the new handle and quite a bit more in the purchase price, perhaps I should consider replacing the handle first.
Lastly, (and this is not related to the handle) I had the hardware on this vintage bag replaced w silver hardware some time ago. Does it hurt the resale value of the bag to have it be silver? I have the old brass hardware, and also could have it changed to gold if I have the handle replaced before I sell it.
Well, from my experience a Kelly handle is $1200-$1500 USD but I have seen lower quoted here recently. They are usually gentler on vintage repair. But it will also take time.
That said, a bag with no handle will be hard to sell.
Does a hardware change affect the value? If it isn't aligned with the stamp, IMO very much so. I'm assuming you have a gold stamp to go with the brass HW. I love palladium HW too - I feel like most vintage lovers prefer gold, but older PHW Kellys are much more rare.
In he end it is marketing. If a buyer thinks there are many repairs, they will expect a lower price, and most buyers don't have a great sense of what a repair will cost. So you want the bag as close to usable as possible. Ideally you want someone who will love the bag for what it is, not what it could be
