Depends on what vibe your looking for and also how patient you can be for inventory. In my experience MP is a more youthful fun vibe, the store is also set up that way with more bright airy feel. All the SA’s in MP seem very friendly and cheery, but they don’t get as much inventory or as quickly as Madison. Madison can be a bit more old school and your experience is definitely dependent on your SA. I also found the MP SA I worked with to be less organized than my Madison SA. Since Madison is a flagship you will get wishlist items a bit faster and they usually get hard to get items first like Madison has already had Pegasus rodeo and is expecting the other color ways within the next two weeks. But I think location is secondary to where you will find an SA you truly click with.