Scarves …..Hermès Fall/Winter 2024 Scarves…..

[textilegirl]

AW24 Scarves So far...

Silk twill 90
18-3-7 (Geoff McFetridge) 004164S cw 02,04,05,07,08,09,10
Bagage à main (Rosa Maria Unda Souki) 004119S cw 01,02,03,04,05,06
Complication Equestre (Octave Marsal) 004148S cw 01,02,05,08,09,10,12
Èmile et une Nuit (Virginie Jamin) 004162S cw 02,03,04,06,07,08,11
Hermès Parade (Jonathan Burton) 004150S cw 01,03,05,06,08,12
Les Folies du Faubourg (Elias Kafouros) 004147S cw 01,03,04,05,06,07,08
Nous Sommes Inséparables (Florence Manlik) 004149S cw 02,03,04,06,07,08,09
Stately Wheels (Stuart Patience) 004163S cw 01,02,04,05,06,07,10,11

Double Face
Caracteristick (Carine Brancowitz) 904165S cw 01,02,03,04,05
Guepards Bandana (Robert Dallet) 904166S cw 01,02,03,04,05
Mille Feuilles de Soie (Natsuno Hidaka) 904126S cw 01,02,03,04,05

Forever Collection
Eperon d’Or (Henri d’Origny)

140 Silk
Jeu des Omnibus au Tampon (Giancarlo Pagni)
Animapolis (Jan Bajtlik)

45cm Gavroche in cashmere/silk
Harnais de Coeur (Daiske Nomura) 744173S cw 02,07,08,12

CSGM
Effet Kaléidoscope (Gianpaolo Pagni) 243800S cw 01,02,04,05,06,07,08
Les Roues de Phaéton Bandana (Pierre Marie) 244170S cw 01,05,06,07,08,10
Lettres Equestres (Internal Creation) 244039S cw 01,03,04,07,08,10,12
Montura de Gaucho (Antonio Carrau) 244185S cw 01,02,04,06,07,08,09
Orto Botanico di Palermo (François Houtin) 244121S cw 01,02,05,06,08,09
Sous le Charme d'Orphée (Alice Shirley) 244177S cw 01,03,04,06,08,09,11

CSGT
Coup de Fouet Chemise (Florence Manlik) 364172S cw 01,02,03,04,05,06
Jungle Love (Robert Dalett) 361876S cw 01,03,04,05,07,08,09
Tulipomanie (Aline Honore) 363964S cw 02,03,04,06,08,11,12

Men’s
100 cashmere/silk
Cheval au Carré (Pierre Charpin) 104131T cw 02,03,04,06,10
Hermès metallique (Viktor Hachmang) 104145T 11 cw 11,13,17,18,19
Roaaaaar! (Alice Shirley) 103957T cw 01,03,05,06,09
Ronds de Marche (Hubert De Watrigant) 102730T cw 01,08,09,14,15

Twilly
In the Pocket (Leigh Cooke)
Guepards
Grand Apparat
Cavalier en Formes
Hermes en Parade
Nous sommes inséparables (Florence Manlik)
Guepard Bandana Franges Cuir

45cm Gavroche
Precious Paradise (Katie Scott)
Becanes
La Berline Bayadère (Wlodek Kaminski) 743864S cw 01,03,04,06,07,08

55cm Bandana

70cm Vintage Silk
Candy Libris (Daiske Nomura) 984151S cw 01,02,04,05,06,09
Faubourg City (Baptiste Virot) 984125S cw 01,02,03,04,06,07,08
I Like Flowers (Leigh Cooke) 984167S cw 01,02,03,04,06,07,11
Palonniers (Hugo Grygkar) 981071S cw 01,05,07,09,10,11,12
Pêle-Mêle Sellier (Thibaut Huchard) 984123S cw 01,04,07,09,11

Men’s (random format)
Roaaaar (Alice Shirley)
Promenade au Faubourg

 

[papertiger]

I need help deciding which colorway to keep! I prefer the caramel/caban/nois because the design is more distinctive but not so sure it likes me😳. Such a tough decision! Please ignore my quick ties and unstyled hair!

IMO, never feel like you have to make a scarf work for you, it should do all the work for you. Unless you're buying the scarf to collect only (or hang on a wall) it has to make you look/feel great when you wear it.

It's clear you have the right instincts: the muted browns don't work, and the black and white looks wonderful on you.

I disagree that the design works better in brown, I think it works even better in monochrome. It's just a different feel. If you think you're buying a 'lesser' version though, don't buy either.

 

[Silkpearls26]

IMO, never feel like you have to make a scarf work for you, it should do all the work for you. Unless you're buying the scarf to collect only (or hang on a wall) it has to make you look/feel great when you wear it.

It's clear you have the right instincts: the muted browns don't work, and the black and white looks wonderful on you.

I disagree that the design works better in brown, I think it works even better in monochrome. It's just a different feel. If you think you're buying a 'lesser' version though, don't buy either.

Just caught up and when I saw the comparative photos a few posts back I was like wow the mono tones make her skin pop! For me the black/ white is a no brainer. But I can appreciate how it’s hard to decide sometimes when we prefer tones that aren’t “our” tones… I think buying what gives us joy is as important as what necessarily suits us better

 

[papertiger]

Just caught up and when I saw the comparative photos a few posts back I was like wow the mono tones make her skin pop! For me the black/ white is a no brainer. But I can appreciate how it’s hard to decide sometimes when we prefer tones that aren’t “our” tones… I think buying what gives us joy is as important as what necessarily suits us better

Of course, and if @makescarvesgreatagain felt that was most important, I'm sure she would have opted for the 'joy'.

As her dilemma indicated, looking good in the scarf was equally important to her, hence dilemma and asking for supportive advice from other members.

 

[makescarvesgreatagain]

Hi, I’ve been using ChatGPT for my own color analysis, and I find it really informative. I added your photos to try out the feature, and here’s what it says!

“the best choice of scarf will depend on her skin tone, hair color, and overall contrast level:

1. First Scarf (Black and White):
• This scarf features high-contrast black and white tones, which tend to suit individuals with cool undertones and high contrast between their hair, skin, and eyes (e.g., Winters).
• On her, it works reasonably well because the crispness complements her likely cool undertones. However, the stark contrast might be a bit overwhelming unless her natural coloring has strong contrasts.

2. Second Scarf (Warm Brown and Black):
• This scarf is more muted and features earthy tones, which align better with Autumn palettes (warm undertones, lower contrast).
• On her, this scarf appears less complementary because it introduces warmth that doesn’t seem to enhance her complexion. Instead, it dulls her features slightly.

Best Choice:
The black and white scarf (first scarf) is a better fit for her coloring. The cool tones and sharper contrast bring out her natural vibrancy more effectively than the warm, muted tones of the second scarf. If she wants to make the second scarf work, pairing it with cooler, high-contrast clothing could help balance the warmth.”

Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts! You have been very helpful and insightful. I have been told I’m a “winter” and I think you are exactly right. Sadly, I am now thinking this may be a scarf I have to pass on. I might be trying too hard to make it work😥

 

[makescarvesgreatagain]

Of course, and if @makescarvesgreatagain felt that was most important, I'm sure she would have opted for the 'joy'.

As her dilemma indicated, looking good in the scarf was equally important to her, hence dilemma and asking for supportive advice from other members.

IMO, never feel like you have to make a scarf work for you, it should do all the work for you. Unless you're buying the scarf to collect only (or hang on a wall) it has to make you look/feel great when you wear it.

It's clear you have the right instincts: the muted browns don't work, and the black and white looks wonderful on you.

I disagree that the design works better in brown, I think it works even better in monochrome. It's just a different feel. If you think you're buying a 'lesser' version though, don't buy either.

Great advice! I think I am trying too hard to make the caramel scarf work.

 

[Smae-ze]

I need help deciding which colorway to keep! I prefer the caramel/caban/nois because the design is more distinctive but not so sure it likes me😳. Such a tough decision! Please ignore my quick ties and unstyled hair!

Both are lovely on you, I think the white pops a bit more.

 

[Redbirdhermes]

My Sous le Charme d'Orphee CSGM in CW03, blanc / jaune vif / rouge, has arrived. As is usually the case for Hermes, the "rouge" is closer to orange in my opinion. Especially when outside under cloudy skies.





A few mod shots with various outer wear.

Baby blue denim jacket - I suspect I have the scarf reversed; however, the backside is nearly as bright as the front side.



Brown linen jacket



Yellow and bright blue sports jacket



Black leather jacket



Brown leather bomber jacket



I don't think this colorway is anything special with the black jacket. It is better with the brown and blue color families. I think it would also work well with a greenish khaki, as there is quite a bit of that color in there. The red is an orange-red, not a blue-red. The hem is medium brown. I really like the light blue color in there. The design is magnificent, and this CSGM is a keeper. I am wearing a small silk scarf to keep the cashmere off my neck. Now to learn to tie pretty knots.

 

[Croisette7]

My Sous le Charme d'Orphee CSGM in CW03, blanc / jaune vif / rouge, has arrived. As is usually the case for Hermes, the "rouge" is closer to orange in my opinion. Especially when outside under cloudy skies.

View attachment 6091902

View attachment 6091903

A few mod shots with various outer wear.

Baby blue denim jacket - I suspect I have the scarf reversed; however, the backside is nearly as bright as the front side.

View attachment 6091904

Brown linen jacket

View attachment 6091915

Yellow and bright blue sports jacket

View attachment 6091906

Black leather jacket

View attachment 6091907

Brown leather bomber jacket

View attachment 6091908

I don't think this colorway is anything special with the black jacket. It is better with the brown and blue color families. I think it would also work well with a greenish khaki, as there is quite a bit of that color in there. The red is an orange-red, not a blue-red. The hem is medium brown. I really like the light blue color in there. The design is magnificent, and this CSGM is a keeper. I am wearing a small silk scarf to keep the cashmere off my neck. Now to learn to tie pretty knots.

Congrats Redbird! It looks great with your cool bomber jacket!

 

[CoastalCouture]

Second new scarf of the season and my first double face 90. A trip to the San Francisco boutique the other day resulted in the purchase of Guepards Bandana in CW 03 vert amanda/bleu/rose. I am thrilled to have a double face and love that both sides are very wearable for me! and I love that the border is a near perfect match for my periwinkle sweater.

 

[CedarWaxWing]

This is an enormously helpful post @cali_to_ny. 🙏 I really appreciate the side by side. I have been almost tempted to wear my Faubourg Tropical to the boutique! I love the one you selected for yourself-- it looks lovely with your hair and coloring.

@Persimmon13-- I completely agree with you and have also developed an "it depends" rule for my own purchases. The wide border is not myfavorite part of Faubourg Tropical CSGM but it works. There is no border on Jardin de Leila au Bloc or Retour a la Nature, for example and of course both of those have contrast hems! I am very eager to see your vert loden Orto.

I agree with everything you have said @etoile de mer -- and I also love the tone-on-tone cws. To this day I would love to find the blue Maharani and the blue Cosmographia, so thei blue Orto, for all the reasons you describe has real gravitational pull...

@LKBNOLA - Same here on finding these two blue shawls, especially the blue Cosmographia! I was mesmerized by it when it was offered on H.com, but had not yet given myself permission to indulge. I am haunted by it! I just opened the 06 Orto this morning and it is so lush and almost 3D when looking at it flat. It's absolutely gorgeous. Still, it does not have the slightly more varied and rich colors of the Cosmographia shawl. I am assessing if the Orto is too similar to my blue Act III and my Nothing but a Dreamer 100 (which I reach for frequently). It definitely looks darker in my photo here than IRL. I am sure I will decide it is different enough to justify keeping it. 🤦🏻‍♀️

 

[CedarWaxWing]

I need help deciding which colorway to keep! I prefer the caramel/caban/nois because the design is more distinctive but not so sure it likes me😳. Such a tough decision! Please ignore my quick ties and unstyled hair!

@makescarvesgreatagain As I clicked through your photos of the Orphee I thought the photos of you in the camel looked quite nice, but then when I clicked through to the Noir Blanc on you, the Wow factor was undeniable!!! Just my little opinion.

 

[Maedi]

My Sous le Charme d'Orphee CSGM in CW03, blanc / jaune vif / rouge, has arrived. As is usually the case for Hermes, the "rouge" is closer to orange in my opinion. Especially when outside under cloudy skies.

View attachment 6091902

View attachment 6091903

A few mod shots with various outer wear.

Baby blue denim jacket - I suspect I have the scarf reversed; however, the backside is nearly as bright as the front side.

View attachment 6091904

Brown linen jacket

View attachment 6091915

Yellow and bright blue sports jacket

View attachment 6091906

Black leather jacket

View attachment 6091907

Brown leather bomber jacket

View attachment 6091908

I don't think this colorway is anything special with the black jacket. It is better with the brown and blue color families. I think it would also work well with a greenish khaki, as there is quite a bit of that color in there. The red is an orange-red, not a blue-red. The hem is medium brown. I really like the light blue color in there. The design is magnificent, and this CSGM is a keeper. I am wearing a small silk scarf to keep the cashmere off my neck. Now to learn to tie pretty knots.

This is such a cheerful, flattering cw for you. I actually like it with black, it caught my eye…perhaps try it with another material than leather.

 

[LKBNOLA]

Hi, I’ve been using ChatGPT for my own color analysis, and I find it really informative. I added your photos to try out the feature, and here’s what it says!

I’m really sorry if my comment came across as unkind—that was absolutely not my intention. I was just sharing how the colorway worked for me personally. I truly value the kindness and diversity of opinions in this community and appreciate everyone’s insights!

How interesting to use Chat GPT for this purpose! And no worries @SilkCouture! It is hard when loved ones (or an SA!) don't appreciate a scarf that we ourselves love. Fortunately, there's always another beauty to choose that will suit. And we have all benefitted from the insight and generosity of this thread, for sure.

Great advice! I think I am trying too hard to make the caramel scarf work.

It is hard when you really want a design to work and the cws are almost but not quite sparking the joy that you would wish @makescarvesgreatagain. I am still on Team Caramel for you, but have you considered any other blanc/noir options like the Tulipomanie triangle? I may be biased because I have it, but it is both bright and soft!

View attachment 6091902

View attachment 6091903

A few mod shots with various outer wear.

Baby blue denim jacket - I suspect I have the scarf reversed; however, the backside is nearly as bright as the front side.

View attachment 6091904

Brown linen jacket

View attachment 6091915

Yellow and bright blue sports jacket

View attachment 6091906

Black leather jacket

View attachment 6091907

Brown leather bomber jacket

View attachment 6091908

I don't think this colorway is anything special with the black jacket. It is better with the brown and blue color families. I think it would also work well with a greenish khaki, as there is quite a bit of that color in there. The red is an orange-red, not a blue-red. The hem is medium brown. I really like the light blue color in there. The design is magnificent, and this CSGM is a keeper. I am wearing a small silk scarf to keep the cashmere off my neck. Now to learn to tie pretty knots.

It is wonderful with your whole closet full of jackets @Redbirdhermes-- so bright and happy. I agree the black jacket does not do much for it, but the brown bomber is my very favorite-- followed by the colorful options. I am so happy for you-- I think the design is wonderful in this format.

Second new scarf of the season and my first double face 90. A trip to the San Francisco boutique the other day resulted in the purchase of Guepards Bandana in CW 03 vert amanda/bleu/rose. I am thrilled to have a double face and love that both sides are very wearable for me! and I love that the border is a near perfect match for my periwinkle sweater.View attachment 6091991View attachment 6091992

Congratulations! This is gorgeous @CoastalCouture -- it was my choice too. I love it on the periwinkle sweater! Both sides are equally wearable for me as well, which is great and not always the case with every DF, though I love the format!

@LKBNOLA - Same here on finding these two blue shawls, especially the blue Cosmographia! I was mesmerized by it when it was offered on H.com, but had not yet given myself permission to indulge. I am haunted by it! I just opened the 06 Orto this morning and it is so lush and almost 3D when looking at it flat. It's absolutely gorgeous. Still, it does not have the slightly more varied and rich colors of the Cosmographia shawl. I am assessing if the Orto is too similar to my blue Act III and my Nothing but a Dreamer 100 (which I reach for frequently). It definitely looks darker in my photo here than IRL. I am sure I will decide it is different enough to justify keeping it. 🤦🏻‍♀️
View attachment 6091996

Thank you for these great side-by-side photos @CedarWaxWing! I also have Nothing But a Dreamer and a few other blues I want to compare. I am coming to the conclusion that I must seethe Orto cws I am interested in person. The light/camera seems to make such a difference in everyone's photos! Maybe one day, we will find the Cosmographia...

 

[rmsworld]

IMO, never feel like you have to make a scarf work for you, it should do all the work for you. Unless you're buying the scarf to collect only (or hang on a wall) it has to make you look/feel great when you wear it.

It's clear you have the right instincts: the muted browns don't work, and the black and white looks wonderful on you.

I disagree that the design works better in brown, I think it works even better in monochrome. It's just a different feel. If you think you're buying a 'lesser' version though, don't buy either.

I Agree (for what it's worth). I do think b/w looks better - at least in the photo.

 

[darkstar66]

My Sous le Charme d'Orphee CSGM in CW03, blanc / jaune vif / rouge, has arrived. As is usually the case for Hermes, the "rouge" is closer to orange in my opinion. Especially when outside under cloudy skies.

View attachment 6091902

View attachment 6091903

A few mod shots with various outer wear.

Baby blue denim jacket - I suspect I have the scarf reversed; however, the backside is nearly as bright as the front side.

View attachment 6091904

Brown linen jacket

View attachment 6091915

Yellow and bright blue sports jacket

View attachment 6091906

Black leather jacket

View attachment 6091907

Brown leather bomber jacket

View attachment 6091908

I don't think this colorway is anything special with the black jacket. It is better with the brown and blue color families. I think it would also work well with a greenish khaki, as there is quite a bit of that color in there. The red is an orange-red, not a blue-red. The hem is medium brown. I really like the light blue color in there. The design is magnificent, and this CSGM is a keeper. I am wearing a small silk scarf to keep the cashmere off my neck. Now to learn to tie pretty knots.

I think this is wonderful on you. It was the only design + cw which interested me this season but when trying it on in the H boutique it was (un)fortunately nothing for me. I envy you!😢