I'm torn between the black suede and the red guccisima.
As lots of people have said above..
#1 is totally classic and the red stripe brightens up the black. It's one of those pieces that if you keep it in good condition, it is absolutely timeless!
#2 is a gorgeous colour but I can see it being dated more easily.
My thoughts are it depends on what you want from your fall bag! Do you want a purse or do you want something more substantial that can also hold a large agenda or mags? Plus consider what you already have in your collection.
Now that I've said all this... hehe.. I've had enough time to process it through my brain
...I vote for #1 because it's timeless, the suede is gorgeous, it's more practical in it's size/shape.. PLUS if you really want red I think there are other red bags out there that are more 'take your breath away'. This red one is more staple...
Best of luck with your choice! Let us know which one you decide on and post a pic with you and your lovely new addition!