Help me choose: third chanel

[nanads]

Hello, beautiful people! So, I’ve been thinking to add my third chanel and contemplating between these 3:
1. Chanel classic M/L flap black caviar


2. Chanel Boy Bag old medium black caviar



3. chanel coco handle small black caviar


I don’t have any preferences on hardware, but it should be black caviar.

I need it to be a day to night bag: quite dressy but can be worn casual too and I think these three bags tick the box.

Two other chanel that I have: mini rectangle black caviar and WOC navy caviar.

Here’s what I have currently in my collection:



So, which chanel do you think would compliment my collection more? Any input will be much appreciated. TIA!

 

[honey52]

My vote is boy bc you already have a small flap, and several beautiful top handles, and the coco handle is very top handly lol. All three are great choices though! Also you have a balenciaga so I feel you might have an edgy side like boys are a bit!

 

[honey52]

Oh oops I think it’s the mini rectangle you have. But still, the boy is a nice shoulder option!

 

[Ruby5]

Boy or classic flap. Boy fills the wardrobe gap (& has crossbody option). Classic is harder to save for and price increases are much sharper. I didn‘t pick coco handle because of your celine, alma bb, & lady dior. But maybe you love top handles? All of your choices are lovely.

 

[redmermaidsoul75]

Hi there!
Definitely the Boy bag. It will be a different alternative to what you already have...it is an iconic of the maison. It can be worn during the day and be so chic for the evening. Ruthenium or gold will look as amazing on a Boy!
All the best and please do come back and show us what you have finally bought. Cheers

 

[redmermaidsoul75]

And the old medium Boy is just perfection!

 

[christy555]

Boy bag! Cuz yoi already have a mini flap in black, unless you won’t mind having two very similar bags. Not a big fan of coco handle sorry

 

[Elisabag]

All great choices but I agree that the Boy bag would broaden your current collection. You exquisite taste!

 

[NYCchihuahua]

If your mini is caviar then I don’t see a point in the ML. Wait for the ML in a seasonal color you like IMO than getting the same color way. Boy bag is really easy to use, so I would go with that first.

 

[topglamchic]

I love all three options.

I agree with everyone. When I looked at your current collection you already have top handles which takes out the need for the coco handle.
While you can’t go wrong with a classic flap the boy will definitely broaden your collection.
Let us know what you choose!!

 

[Cclover2013]

Out of the three I would do the classic flap. Some may say it’s too similar to your mini but i see the value in having both

 

[Bagaholic9]

I voted the classic flap. Simply, and honestly, because they are becoming so ridiculously expensive.

 

[lvchanellvr]

I voted for the CF as you don't own one. No to the CCH as the Alma is similar to the CCH. CCH is notorious for its corner wear. If money isn't an object, I would add the boy bag too (either small or old medium size).

 

[Cinderelladress]

Classic flap first (but not in black ) and then boy later

 

[angersauce]

You seem to like your top handles, contrary to others I'm going to go with the Coco. It's more dressy for night time than the Alma and Luggage. Color wise it makes sense since you don't have a black bag in that silhouette. Classic flap is too similar to your mini, unless you find yourself desperately wanting more space every time you use the mini. You can't go wrong really although I don't like the Boy as much since it's not quite as timeless (I say this as a person who loved the boy when it came out, but as I got older, meh.)

Nice taste, btw, love your collection, that practical color palate is perfect.