Sheren, when I bought my first Bbag, I knew I wanted something other than black. Like you, 99% of my other bags were black. I decided to go for an ink city. I've never regretted it! Ink will probably be harder to find now, but I think they pop up on ebay from time to time.
If you decide to purchase one from a store, then I would vote for the grenat or blue india. Both are versatile colors, and it would look great against your black wardrobe. And as the other ladies suggested, the greige would be a good choice too.
That's my only problem with these Bbags. So many colors, so little money!
Good luck, and let us know what you decide to get!
money money money... more more more...so that... b bag bbag bbag...more more more...