Possibly another Rogue, in regular size, but I just bought my first Rogue, a 25 in Utility, this past weekend, so I want to see how the smaller size works for me. (I have always been a "big" bag person, but am really trying to downsize, so we'll see...). For those of you who mentioned maybe wanting something different, I did see a Rogue 25 in the Chevron pattern quilting with tiny rivets. It was in the Dusty Rose color and is just a stunning bag! It is a much dressier bag than the original Rogues which are more casual, IMO.
I would also love something with those adorable penguins too!