I could use some advice here... I sold a $700 pair of boots, and the buyer is listed as based in China (I'm in NYC). The shipping address stuck out to me, and it turns out it is a warehouse facility in City of Industry, CA. Basically, when you google the address the first thing that comes up is a thread on BadBuyerList. The name of my buyer appears in that thread, but in the context of other people who have found the thread & asking "they paid, and said not to include invoice because it's a gift... should I cancel?". Indeed, the buyer has paid already, and in the transaction notes asked me to bubble wrap it and not include an invoice, as it is a gift.
I called and spoke to a couple people at eBay to get their advice. The guy from escalation in seller protection told me that he saw no issues with the account (they do have over 1k all-positive feedback, within the past 12 months), and verified that this is the address they have items shipped to. He said that as long as I send the item to the address they give me and it shows as delivered, I'm covered. I asked what happens if for whatever reason it doesn't end up showing as delivered... and he said that at that point it would be hard for them to side with me. He said to send it signature confirmation and insured.
I'm conflicted because: 1) I don't want to cancel a transaction from a legitimate buyer, upset them, and risk the ding on my account, but 2) I'm very hesitant given the situation and the cost of the boots (which were ~$1.6k retail, barely used)...
Has anyone ever encountered anything like this before? What would you do? :/